Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery
232 North Wallace St, PO Box 610, Ellsworth, WI 54011. EIN 39-0262200. Self-fundedPlan year 2025
Manufacturing (NAICS 311500)
Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery (Ellsworth, WI, 294 participants) has a self-funded health plan. Its brokers of record are Cottingham & Butler, GIS Benefits and Jennon Caruth, paid 19% of reported premium (median for this size: 3.6%). Coverage renews in January.
- Participants
- 294
- Funding
- Self-funded
- Renews
- January
- Premium
- $512,293
- Comp rate
- 19%
- Brokers of record
- Cottingham & Butler
GIS Benefits
Jennon Caruth - Carriers by line
- Plan year
- 2025
- Source
- Form 5500, filed 2026
Schedule A contracts, plan year 2025
| Lines | Carrier | Policy year | Covered | Premium | Per covered / mo | Broker comp | Comp rate | Paid to |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dental, AD&D, LTD, EAP, STD, Life Accidental Death & Dismemberment, VOL. Life, and Employee Assistance Program |
Symetra | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
291 | $231,643 | $66 median $47 |
$28,332 | 12% typical · median 10% |
Cottingham & Butler |
| Dental | Delta Dental | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
230 | $174,334 experience-rated |
$63 median $47 |
$19,026 | 11% typical · median 10% |
Cottingham & Butler |
| Accident, Hospital Indemnity, Critical Illness Critical Illness, Accident, Hospital Indemnity |
Symetra | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
134 | $50,103 | $31 median $43 |
$10,295 | 21% typical · median 17% |
Cottingham & Butler |
| Other Transplant |
UnitedHealthcare | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
478 | $37,385 | $7 median $31 |
$3,739 | 10% typical · median 13% |
Cottingham & Butler |
| Vision | Ameritas | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
402 | $18,828 | $4 median $21 |
$1,883 | 10% typical · median 9.1% |
Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv |
| AD&D, LTD, EAP, STD, Life, Hospital Indemnity, Vision, Dental Accidental Death & Dismemberment, VOL. Life , Hospital Indemnity, EAP |
MetLife | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
0 | — | — | $27,113 | — | Cottingham & Butler GIS Benefits Jennon Caruth |
| Other | MetLife | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
0 | — | — | $1,325 | — | Cottingham & Butler GIS Benefits Jennon Caruth |
| Critical Illness Critical Illness |
MetLife | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
0 | — | — | $1,705 | — | Cottingham & Butler GIS Benefits Jennon Caruth |
| Accident Accident |
MetLife | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
0 | — | — | $1,714 | — | Cottingham & Butler GIS Benefits Jennon Caruth |
| Total | $512,293 | $95,132 | 19% |
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. Commissions and fees as reported. Per covered / mo = premium ÷ covered lives ÷ 12, with the median for the same line and group size.
Premium by plan year
Brokers
| Broker | Since | Broker comp |
|---|---|---|
| Cottingham & Butler Insurance agent or broker · Dubuque, IA · fees for Group Volume Bonus; Supplemental Compensation Non-monetary Compensation | 2021 | $80,039 |
| GIS Benefits Insurance agent or broker · Morris, IL · fees for Supplemental Compensation | 2021 | $7,700 |
| Jennon Caruth Insurance agent or broker · Minneapolis, MN · fees for Supplemental Compensation | 2022 | $5,510 |
| Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv Insurance agent or broker · Dubuque, IA | 2025 | $1,883 |
Other service providers
| Provider | Service | Fees |
|---|
Schedule C: providers paid $5,000 or more by the plan, mostly on large and self-funded plans. Roles come from the filing's service codes.
Plan-year history, 2019–2025
| Plan year | Participants | Premium | Broker comp | Medical funding | Top carriers | Brokers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 294 | $512K | $95K | Self-funded | Symetra, Delta Dental, UnitedHealthcare | Cottingham & Butler, GIS Benefits, Jennon Caruth |
| 2024 | 286 | $576K | $102K | Self-funded | MetLife, UnitedHealthcare | Cottingham & Butler, GIS Benefits, Jennon Caruth |
| 2023 | 284 | $428K | $116K | Self-funded | MetLife, UnitedHealthcare | Cottingham & Butler, GIS Benefits, Jennon Caruth |
| 2022 | 247 | $400K | $52K | Self-funded | MetLife, UnitedHealthcare | Cottingham & Butler, GIS Benefits, Jennon Caruth |
| 2021 | 182 | $340K | $92K | Self-funded | MetLife, UnitedHealthcare | North Risk Partners, Mark Mettille, GIS Benefits |
| 2020 | 171 | $204K | $16K | Self-funded | Delta Dental, Unum / Colonial, Starmount Life Insurance | North Risk Partners, North Risk Partners St Paul |
| 2019 | 167 | $228K | $15K | Self-funded | Delta Dental, Unum / Colonial, Superior Vision Insurance Plan of Wisconsin | North Risk Partners, North Risk Partners St Paul |
Across all of this employer's welfare plans, as filed. Years with missing or partial filings show smaller totals.
Plans
| Plan | Type | Funding | Participants | Filing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery Health and Welfare Benefits Wrap Plan (plan 599) Plan year Jan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025 · received Jul 16, 2026 | Health, Dental, Vision, Life, Death benefits, Temporary disability, Long-term disability, Other | Insurance + General assets | 294 | Filing PDF |
What this page can't tell you: Schedule A reports insurance contracts, not enrollment by plan, and self-funded claims don't appear on it. Plans under 100 participants often don't file. Data as filed with the U.S. Department of Labor through Oct 24, 2026. Something wrong? Report a data issue.