Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv

Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings

Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv is the broker of record for 23 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 11,081 participants, most in IL, TN, WI. Commissions and fees average 13% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on.

Employers
23
Participants
11,081
Premium placed
$2.8M
Commissions + fees
$358K
Comp rate
13%

See all brokers in Open5500 →

Where the book is

Carriers on this book

Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.

Group size and funding

Recent wins (0)

None in the latest two plan years.

Recent losses (0)

None in the latest two plan years.

A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

Largest employers

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Davenport, IA
1,756Self-fundedJan$3.8M
Hirschbach Motor Lines, Inc.
Dubuque, IA
1,591Self-fundedJan$2.9M
Wisconsin Illinois Senior Housing, Inc.
Crystal Lake, IL
1,512No medical reportedJun$427K
Cirtec Medical Corporation
Brooklyn Park, MN
1,274Self-fundedJan$1.2M
Heritage Communities
Omaha, NE
802Self-fundedJan$768K
American Bulk Commodities Inc.
Youngstown, OH
763Self-fundedJan$1.1M
GP Transportation Co.
Darien, IL
465Self-fundedJan$265K
Custom Assembly Inc
Haviland, OH
349Self-fundedAug$506K
Logisteed America, Inc.
Torrance, CA
335Fully insuredJan$1.1M
Ellsworth Cooperative Creamery
Ellsworth, WI
294Self-fundedJan$512K
Dial Packaging, LLC
Lewisburg, TN
243Self-fundedJan$347K
Hoffman Transportation, Inc.
Channahon, IL
233Self-fundedJan$548K
Veriha Trucking, Inc.
Marinette, WI
211Self-fundedJan$249K
Lewisburg Printing Company
Lewisburg, TN
192Fully insuredMay$919K
Doyle Equipment Manufacturing Company
Palmyra, MO
190Self-fundedJun$180K
Johnson Feed, Inc.
Canton, SD
190Self-fundedMar$529K
Fleetmaster Express, Inc.
Roanoke, VA
185Self-fundedNov$269K
Coker Tire Company
Chattanooga, TN
163Fully insuredJul$1.2M
Richard McNay, Inc.
Quincy, IL
133Self-fundedFeb$146K
Great Plains Transport, Inc.
Mapleton, ND
104Fully insuredJan$740K
Usher Transport, Inc.
Louisville, KY
96Self-fundedJan$278K
Woolf Distributing Company, Inc.
Woodstock, IL
0Fully insuredJan$999K
Diversified Maintenance, LLC.
Tampa, FL
0Fully insuredJan$3.1M

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.