Cottingham & Butler
Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings
Cottingham & Butler is the broker of record for 441 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 274,593 participants, most in WI, IL, IA. Commissions and fees average 6.2% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 20 and lost 4 broker-of-record relationships.
Employers
441
Participants
274,593
Premium placed
$461M
Commissions + fees
$28.8M
Comp rate
6.2%
Where the book is
Carriers on this book
- MetLife 103
- Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans) 61
- Sun Life 55
- UnitedHealthcare 55
- Unum / Colonial 53
- Delta Dental 52
- Mutual of Omaha 51
- VSP 42
- Symetra 39
- EyeMed / Fidelity Security Life 34
Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.
Group size and funding
- 0–49 participants 22
- 50–99 participants 15
- 100–249 participants 191
- 250–499 participants 90
- 500–999 participants 71
- 1,000–4,999 participants 45
- 5,000+ participants 7
- Self-funded 220 (50%)
- Fully insured 167 (38%)
- No medical reported 32 (7%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 16 (4%)
- Unknown 5 (1%)
- Mixed 1 (0%)
Recent wins (20)
| Employer | Previous broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Heartland Express, Inc of Iowa North Liberty, IA | Lockton | 2025 |
| J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc Neenah, WI | USI Insurance Services | 2025 |
| Empirical Technology, Inc. Dakota Dunes, SD | USI Insurance Services | 2025 |
| Shive-hattery Group Inc. Cedar Rapids, IA | ATD Employer Solutions in | 2025 |
| Wacker Neuson America Corporation Menomonee Falls, WI | Hausmann Group | 2025 |
| Modern Forge Companies, LLC Merrillville, IN | HUB International | 2025 |
| Flavorchem Corporation Downers Grove, IL | Horton Group | 2025 |
| Anderson Diesel Truck Service, Inc. Eagan, MN | Brown & Brown | 2025 |
| University of Dubuque Dubuque, IA | Mercer | 2025 |
| Postle Aluminum Company Elkhart, IN | EOI Service | 2024 |
| Palmer College Foundation Davenport, IA | Gallagher | 2025 |
| Veriha Trucking, Inc. Marinette, WI | Hylant | 2025 |
| Certified Express, Inc Neosho, MO | Croley Insurance and Financial | 2025 |
| Building Products Inc. Watertown, SD | Freimark and Associates | 2025 |
| CG Schmidt Milwaukee, WI | R and R Insurance Services | 2025 |
| Chemoil Energy Services LLC Oklahoma City, OK | Municipal Benefits | 2025 |
| LGT Transport, LLC Omaha, NE | Midwest Benefit Advisors | 2024 |
| Educational Credential Evaluators Inc Milwaukee, WI | USI Insurance Services | 2025 |
| Soft Landing Interventions, LLC Naperville, IL | HUB International | 2025 |
| Woolf Distributing Company, Inc. Woodstock, IL | Duncan Financial | 2024 |
Recent losses (4)
| Employer | New broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Moore Holding Company West Fargo, ND | Brown & Brown | 2025 |
| Coastal Carriers Truck Lines LLC Troy, MO | Robert E Miller Insurance Agency | 2025 |
| Hutchison, Inc. Adams City, CO | Brown & Brown | 2025 |
| EIP Manufacturing, LLC Earlville, IA | AssuredPartners | 2025 |
A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kwik Trip, Inc. LA Crosse, WI | 34,045 | Self-funded | Oct | $16.7M |
| Rush University Medical Center Chicago, IL | 12,073 | Self-funded | Jan | $19.5M |
| Thor Industries, Inc. Elkhart, IN | 9,896 | Self-funded | Jan | $13.0M |
| Packers Holdings, LLC Kieler, WI | 7,617 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.2M |
| Kirkland & Ellis, LLP Chicago, IL | 7,521 | Self-funded | Jan | $8.1M |
| Industrial Technologies and Services, LLC Davidson, NC | 6,221 | Self-funded | Jan | $10.3M |
| Crst, the Transportation Solution, Inc. Cedar Rapids, IA | 5,071 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.0M |
| Heartland Express, Inc of Iowa North Liberty, IA | 3,600 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.8M |
| McCoy Group Inc. Dubuque, IA | 3,554 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.8M |
| Claires Stores, Inc. Hoffman Estates, IL | 2,514 | Self-funded | May | $1.5M |
| J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc Neenah, WI | 2,507 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.2M |
| Pulitzer, Inc. Davenport, IA | 2,495 | Mixed | Jan | $21.6M |
| Fishel Company Columbus, OH | 2,415 | Fully insured | Apr | $26.7M |
| Rockline Industries, Inc. Sheboygan, WI | 2,394 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.6M |
| Premium Transportation Staffing, Inc. Medina, OH | 2,183 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.3M |
| Marelli North America, Inc. Shelbyville, TN | 2,180 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.5M |
| Copley Memorial Hospital Aurora, IL | 2,153 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $12.3M |
| Saginaw Chippewa Indian Tribe of MI Mt. Pleasant, MI | 2,136 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.7M |
| Vonachen Group, Inc. Peoria, IL | 2,063 | Fully insured | Jul | $4.7M |
| Agropur Inc. Appleton, WI | 2,023 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.7M |
| Sagility Operations, Inc. Westminster, CO | 1,958 | Self-funded | Jan | $884K |
| HGS USA, LLC Peoria, IL | 1,958 | Self-funded | Jan | $535K |
| Lands' END, Inc. Dodgeville, WI | 1,928 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.9M |
| Lee Enterprises, Inc. Davenport, IA | 1,756 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.8M |
| Niemann Foods Inc Quincy, IL | 1,746 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $11.8M |
| Orthomidwest Pllc Rockford, IL | 1,723 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.2M |
| Kasai North America, Inc. Murfreesboro, TN | 1,663 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.2M |
| Carter Express, Inc. Anderson, IN | 1,655 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.0M |
| RJW Logistics Group Inc. Woodridge, IL | 1,608 | Fully insured | Mar | $8.1M |
| Hirschbach Motor Lines, Inc. Dubuque, IA | 1,591 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.9M |
| Running Supply, Inc. Marshall, MN | 1,578 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.1M |
| Long Iron Services, LLC. Oakbrook, IL | 1,523 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.7M |
| Wisconsin Illinois Senior Housing, Inc. Crystal Lake, IL | 1,512 | No medical reported | Jun | $427K |
| AY McDonald Industries Inc Dubuque, IA | 1,440 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.2M |
| MR. Bult's Inc. Burnham, IL | 1,434 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.8M |
| Novo Building Products, LLC Zeeland, MI | 1,401 | Fully insured | Jan | $12.9M |
| Cottingham & Butler Insurance Services, Inc. Dubuque, IA | 1,393 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $1.7M |
| Fleet Farm Group LLC Appleton, WI | 1,382 | Self-funded | Jul | $1.2M |
| Daniels Sharpsmart, Inc. Chicago, IL | 1,309 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.2M |
| Holland Hospital Holland, MI | 1,290 | Self-funded | Apr | $2.7M |
| Lily Transportation Corp. Needham, MA | 1,283 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.6M |
| Empirical Technology, Inc. Dakota Dunes, SD | 1,226 | Self-funded | Jan | $724K |
| Western Express, Inc. Nashville, TN | 1,196 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.4M |
| Airxcel, Inc. Wichita, KS | 1,190 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.2M |
| Hibu Inc. Cedar Rapids, IA | 1,125 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.1M |
| Club Car, LLC Augusta, GA | 1,087 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.7M |
| BBQ Holdings, Inc. Minnetonka, MN | 1,070 | Self-funded | Jan | $687K |
| Dakota Supply Group, Inc Fargo, ND | 1,043 | Self-funded | Jan | $928K |
| Fenix Management LLC DBA Fenix Parts Hurst, TX | 1,035 | Self-funded | Jan | $746K |
| Hyperion Materials & Technologies, Inc. Worthington, OH | 1,015 | Fully insured | Jan | $3.3M |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.