Cottingham & Butler

Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings

Cottingham & Butler is the broker of record for 441 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 274,593 participants, most in WI, IL, IA. Commissions and fees average 6.2% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 20 and lost 4 broker-of-record relationships.

Employers
441
Participants
274,593
Premium placed
$461M
Commissions + fees
$28.8M
Comp rate
6.2%

See all brokers in Open5500 →

Where the book is

Carriers on this book

Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.

Group size and funding

Recent wins (20)

EmployerPrevious brokerPlan year
Heartland Express, Inc of Iowa
North Liberty, IA
Lockton2025
J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc
Neenah, WI
USI Insurance Services2025
Empirical Technology, Inc.
Dakota Dunes, SD
USI Insurance Services2025
Shive-hattery Group Inc.
Cedar Rapids, IA
ATD Employer Solutions in2025
Wacker Neuson America Corporation
Menomonee Falls, WI
Hausmann Group2025
Modern Forge Companies, LLC
Merrillville, IN
HUB International2025
Flavorchem Corporation
Downers Grove, IL
Horton Group2025
Anderson Diesel Truck Service, Inc.
Eagan, MN
Brown & Brown2025
University of Dubuque
Dubuque, IA
Mercer2025
Postle Aluminum Company
Elkhart, IN
EOI Service2024
Palmer College Foundation
Davenport, IA
Gallagher2025
Veriha Trucking, Inc.
Marinette, WI
Hylant2025
Certified Express, Inc
Neosho, MO
Croley Insurance and Financial2025
Building Products Inc.
Watertown, SD
Freimark and Associates2025
CG Schmidt
Milwaukee, WI
R and R Insurance Services2025
Chemoil Energy Services LLC
Oklahoma City, OK
Municipal Benefits2025
LGT Transport, LLC
Omaha, NE
Midwest Benefit Advisors2024
Educational Credential Evaluators Inc
Milwaukee, WI
USI Insurance Services2025
Soft Landing Interventions, LLC
Naperville, IL
HUB International2025
Woolf Distributing Company, Inc.
Woodstock, IL
Duncan Financial2024

Recent losses (4)

EmployerNew brokerPlan year
Moore Holding Company
West Fargo, ND
Brown & Brown2025
Coastal Carriers Truck Lines LLC
Troy, MO
Robert E Miller Insurance Agency2025
Hutchison, Inc.
Adams City, CO
Brown & Brown2025
EIP Manufacturing, LLC
Earlville, IA
AssuredPartners2025

A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

Largest employers

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
Kwik Trip, Inc.
LA Crosse, WI
34,045Self-fundedOct$16.7M
Rush University Medical Center
Chicago, IL
12,073Self-fundedJan$19.5M
Thor Industries, Inc.
Elkhart, IN
9,896Self-fundedJan$13.0M
Packers Holdings, LLC
Kieler, WI
7,617Self-fundedJan$3.2M
Kirkland & Ellis, LLP
Chicago, IL
7,521Self-fundedJan$8.1M
Industrial Technologies and Services, LLC
Davidson, NC
6,221Self-fundedJan$10.3M
Crst, the Transportation Solution, Inc.
Cedar Rapids, IA
5,071Self-fundedJan$5.0M
Heartland Express, Inc of Iowa
North Liberty, IA
3,600Self-fundedJan$5.8M
McCoy Group Inc.
Dubuque, IA
3,554Self-fundedJan$1.8M
Claires Stores, Inc.
Hoffman Estates, IL
2,514Self-fundedMay$1.5M
J. J. Keller & Associates, Inc
Neenah, WI
2,507Self-fundedJan$1.2M
Pulitzer, Inc.
Davenport, IA
2,495MixedJan$21.6M
Fishel Company
Columbus, OH
2,415Fully insuredApr$26.7M
Rockline Industries, Inc.
Sheboygan, WI
2,394Self-fundedJan$1.6M
Premium Transportation Staffing, Inc.
Medina, OH
2,183Self-fundedJan$1.3M
Marelli North America, Inc.
Shelbyville, TN
2,180Self-fundedJan$3.5M
Copley Memorial Hospital
Aurora, IL
2,153Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$12.3M
Saginaw Chippewa Indian Tribe of MI
Mt. Pleasant, MI
2,136Self-fundedJan$1.7M
Vonachen Group, Inc.
Peoria, IL
2,063Fully insuredJul$4.7M
Agropur Inc.
Appleton, WI
2,023Self-fundedJan$2.7M
Sagility Operations, Inc.
Westminster, CO
1,958Self-fundedJan$884K
HGS USA, LLC
Peoria, IL
1,958Self-fundedJan$535K
Lands' END, Inc.
Dodgeville, WI
1,928Self-fundedJan$1.9M
Lee Enterprises, Inc.
Davenport, IA
1,756Self-fundedJan$3.8M
Niemann Foods Inc
Quincy, IL
1,746Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$11.8M
Orthomidwest Pllc
Rockford, IL
1,723Self-fundedJan$2.2M
Kasai North America, Inc.
Murfreesboro, TN
1,663Self-fundedJan$3.2M
Carter Express, Inc.
Anderson, IN
1,655Self-fundedJan$2.0M
RJW Logistics Group Inc.
Woodridge, IL
1,608Fully insuredMar$8.1M
Hirschbach Motor Lines, Inc.
Dubuque, IA
1,591Self-fundedJan$2.9M
Running Supply, Inc.
Marshall, MN
1,578Self-fundedJan$1.1M
Long Iron Services, LLC.
Oakbrook, IL
1,523Self-fundedJan$2.7M
Wisconsin Illinois Senior Housing, Inc.
Crystal Lake, IL
1,512No medical reportedJun$427K
AY McDonald Industries Inc
Dubuque, IA
1,440Self-fundedJan$1.2M
MR. Bult's Inc.
Burnham, IL
1,434Self-fundedJan$1.8M
Novo Building Products, LLC
Zeeland, MI
1,401Fully insuredJan$12.9M
Cottingham & Butler Insurance Services, Inc.
Dubuque, IA
1,393Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$1.7M
Fleet Farm Group LLC
Appleton, WI
1,382Self-fundedJul$1.2M
Daniels Sharpsmart, Inc.
Chicago, IL
1,309Self-fundedJan$1.2M
Holland Hospital
Holland, MI
1,290Self-fundedApr$2.7M
Lily Transportation Corp.
Needham, MA
1,283Self-fundedJan$2.6M
Empirical Technology, Inc.
Dakota Dunes, SD
1,226Self-fundedJan$724K
Western Express, Inc.
Nashville, TN
1,196Self-fundedJan$2.4M
Airxcel, Inc.
Wichita, KS
1,190Self-fundedJan$2.2M
Hibu Inc.
Cedar Rapids, IA
1,125Self-fundedJan$2.1M
Club Car, LLC
Augusta, GA
1,087Self-fundedJan$1.7M
BBQ Holdings, Inc.
Minnetonka, MN
1,070Self-fundedJan$687K
Dakota Supply Group, Inc
Fargo, ND
1,043Self-fundedJan$928K
Fenix Management LLC DBA Fenix Parts
Hurst, TX
1,035Self-fundedJan$746K
Hyperion Materials & Technologies, Inc.
Worthington, OH
1,015Fully insuredJan$3.3M

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.