Broker compensation on group benefits, 2026

What Form 5500 filings show, plan years 2024 and 2025

Every employer that files a Form 5500 for its health and welfare plans reports, on Schedule A, what each insurer paid brokers on its contracts. This report sums up 290,479 contracts from 66,358 employers: $8.3B of commissions and fees on $230B of premium. It's written for brokers who want to know where they stand, and for anyone who wants to understand how group benefits brokers are paid. The figures describe the market as a whole; no firm is singled out.

By line of coverage

LineContractsPay a brokerMedianMiddle half
Medical61,99278%4.3%2.9–5.7%
Stop-Loss5,74933%7.0%4.7–11.0%
Dental20,26982%7.7%4.6–10.4%
Vision28,90576%9.9%5.4–10.8%
Life12,31587%13.4%6.6–18.6%
AD&D1,96490%15.0%11.0–19.6%
STD10,89894%15.0%9.5–19.4%
LTD14,58494%14.9%8.5–19.1%
Accident5,83198%20.4%15.3–25.8%
Critical Illness6,50397%20.0%15.0–25.0%
Hospital Indemnity3,91397%20.9%16.4–26.6%
Legal6,03791%12.3%10.0–16.7%

Broker pay (commissions plus fees) as a share of the contract's premium, among contracts that pay a broker. "Middle half" runs from the 25th to the 75th percentile. Medical counts every insured medical contract (often bundled with Rx, dental or vision); every other line counts contracts covering only that line.

Medical, by group size

ParticipantsContractsMedianMiddle half
Under 1003,0264.9%3.4–6.1%
100–24923,3564.6%3.3–5.9%
250–49910,2614.1%2.9–5.5%
500–9994,9333.8%2.2–5.3%
1,000–4,9994,3143.5%1.9–5.4%
5,000+2,3662.6%1.5–5.0%

Insured medical contracts that pay a broker, by the employer's plan participants. Plans under 100 participants are mostly exempt from filing, so that row reflects the smaller groups that do file.

Over time

4.2% 2019 4.3% 2020 4.3% 2021 4.3% 2022 4.3% 2023 4.3% 2024 4.2% 2025
Median broker pay on insured medical contracts that pay a broker, by plan year. 2025 is still filling in: many plans haven't filed yet.
21% 2019 21% 2020 22% 2021 22% 2022 23% 2023 23% 2024 24% 2025
Fees as a share of all commissions and fees reported on Schedule A, by plan year.

Medical, by state

StateContractsMedian
Arizona8185.2%
Georgia1,1195.1%
Tennessee8935.1%
Oklahoma4045.0%
Maryland8575.0%
Florida3,4285.0%
California10,7955.0%
Louisiana4424.9%
New Jersey1,0754.9%
Nevada3614.8%
Utah5534.8%
Texas3,7554.7%
Colorado6654.7%
District of Columbia4364.5%
New York3,0254.1%
Illinois2,2974.0%
South Carolina3844.0%
Connecticut5904.0%
Washington8314.0%
Missouri5724.0%
Virginia1,4053.8%
Pennsylvania1,6503.5%
Ohio1,2963.5%
Indiana3983.4%
North Carolina8353.3%
Michigan2,1653.3%
Minnesota7383.1%
Oregon6693.0%
Kentucky3933.0%
Massachusetts1,7192.7%
Wisconsin7532.4%

States with at least 300 insured medical contracts that pay a broker, by the employer's state, highest median first. Differences reflect group sizes, carriers and local practice as much as anything else.

Using these benchmarks

How we calculated this

Cite this report: Open5500, "Broker compensation on group benefits, 2026," www.open5500.com/reports/broker-compensation. Data: U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500, Schedule A.