Richard McNay, Inc.
Quincy, IL 62301 · Transportation & warehousing · EIN 37-1027643
2025 plan yearSelf-funded
Richard McNay, Inc. (Quincy, IL, 133 participants) has a self-funded health plan. Its brokers of record are Cottingham & Butler, Midwest Insurance Solutions and Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv, paid 14% of reported premium (median for this size: 4.4%). Coverage renews in February.
Participants
133
Renews
Feb
Schedule A premium
$146K
Broker comp
$20K
Comp rate
14%
Carriers by line
Insurance contracts (Schedule A)
| Lines | Carrier | Policy year | Covered | Premium | Broker comp | Comp rate | Paid to |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dental, Accident, Hospital Indemnity, AD&D, LTD, Critical Illness, STD, Life Accidental Death & Dismemberment. Critical Illness, Accident, Hospital Indemnity, Voluntary Life/ad&d |
Symetra | Aug 1, 2025 to Jan 31, 2026 |
133 | $51,773 | $8,234 | 16% typical · median 11% |
Cottingham & Butler |
| AD&D, Life, Vision, Dental Accidental Death & Dismemberment |
Principal | Feb 1, 2025 to Jul 31, 2025 |
113 | $45,854 | $5,967 | 13% typical · median 11% |
Midwest Insurance Solutions |
| STD | American Heritage Life Insurance | Feb 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
— | $23,298 | $2,330 | 10% below typical · median 15% |
Midwest Insurance Solutions |
| Vision, Dental | Ameritas | Aug 1, 2025 to Jan 31, 2026 |
180 | $18,951 | $3,110 | 16% above typical · median 11% |
Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv |
| Dental, AD&D, Life Accidental Death & Dismemberment |
Dearborn Life Insurance | Feb 1, 2025 to Jul 31, 2025 |
161 | $5,731 | $827 | 14% typical · median 11% |
Cottingham & Butler |
Brokers and agents paid
| Firm | Location | Contracts | Commissions + fees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cottingham & Butler | Dubuque, IA | 2 | $9,061 |
| Midwest Insurance Solutions | Quicny, IL | 2 | $8,297 |
| Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv | Dubuque, IA | 1 | $3,110 |
Plan-year history, 2019–2025
| Plan year | Participants | Premium | Broker comp | Medical funding | Top carriers | Brokers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 133 | $146K | $20K | Self-funded | Symetra, Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance | Cottingham & Butler, Midwest Insurance Solutions, Cottingham Butler Insurance Serv |
| 2024 | 144 | $134K | $16K | Self-funded | Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance | Midwest Insurance Solutions |
| 2023 | 163 | $145K | $18K | Self-funded | Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance | Midwest Insurance Solutions |
| 2022 | 305 | $2.8M | $64K | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance | R W Garrett Agency, Midwest Insurance Solutions |
| 2021 | 296 | $2.5M | $66K | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance | R W Garrett Agency, Midwest Insurance Solutions |
| 2020 | 168 | $2.1M | $60K | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance | R W Garrett Agency, Midwest Insurance Solutions |
| 2019 | 153 | $2.0M | $59K | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance | R W Garrett Agency, Midwest Insurance Solutions |
Across all of this employer's welfare plans, as filed. Years with missing or partial filings show smaller totals.
Health and welfare plans
| Plan # | Plan | Plan year | Participants | Received | Original |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 501 | Richard McNay, Inc. Employee Benefits Plan | Feb 1, 2025 – Jan 31, 2026 | 133 | Oct 1, 2026 | Filing PDF |
Data as filed with the U.S. Department of Labor, through Oct 24, 2026. Something wrong? Report a data issue.