Employee benefits in Wisconsin
1,586 employers in Wisconsin file a Form 5500 for health and welfare plans, covering 1,361,690 participants. The most common medical carriers are UnitedHealthcare, Quartz Health Benefit Plans, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), and the most common brokers are Insurance Solutions, USI Insurance Services, Cottingham & Butler. Median broker compensation is 6.0% of premium.
Fully insured group health market share, MLR and rebates (2024)
Small group · $993M premium · 135,094 covered lives · 16 carriers · $9.5M in rebates owed
| Carrier | Premium | Covered lives | Share | MLR (3-yr) | Rebate owed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| UnitedHealthcare | $273M | 41,995 | 28% | 76% | $9.0M |
| Anthem / Elevance | $248M | 29,257 | 25% | 80% | $420K |
| Quartz Health Benefit Plans | $169M | 23,738 | 17% | 91% | — |
| Medica Insurance | $95.8M | 13,536 | 9.7% | 96% | — |
| Group Health Cooperative of South Central Wisconsin | $53.0M | 7,550 | 5.3% | 95% | — |
| Security Health Plan of Wisconsin | $41.2M | 4,812 | 4.2% | 91% | — |
| Healthpartners Insurance | $33.4M | 3,628 | 3.4% | 105% | — |
| Wisconsin Physicians Service Insurance | $21.8M | 1,733 | 2.2% | 98% | — |
| Common Ground Healthcare Cooperative | $14.5M | 3,079 | 1.5% | 96% | — |
| Network Health Plan | $14.2M | 1,776 | 1.4% | 86% | — |
Large group · $6.1B premium · 842,186 covered lives · 17 carriers · $7.2M in rebates owed
| Carrier | Premium | Covered lives | Share | MLR (3-yr) | Rebate owed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quartz Health Benefit Plans | $1.3B | 195,702 | 21% | 94% | — |
| Anthem / Elevance | $1.2B | 140,947 | 20% | 92% | — |
| Medica Insurance | $1.1B | 159,524 | 18% | 89% | — |
| UnitedHealthcare | $905M | 131,122 | 15% | 85% | $7.2M |
| Group Health Cooperative of South Central Wisconsin | $363M | 52,616 | 5.9% | 93% | — |
| Security Health Plan of Wisconsin | $291M | 39,892 | 4.8% | 94% | — |
| Network Health Plan | $245M | 34,132 | 4.0% | 86% | — |
| Healthpartners Insurance | $236M | 31,583 | 3.9% | 92% | — |
| Aspirus Health Plan, Inc. | $114M | 15,328 | 1.9% | 97% | — |
| Group Health Cooperative of EAU Claire | $98.9M | 12,454 | 1.6% | 110% | — |
Fully insured comprehensive medical only, from insurers' 2024 Medical Loss Ratio reports to CMS (published about two years later). MLR is the official 3-year, credibility-adjusted share of premium spent on claims and quality improvement (2022–2024); the federal minimum is 80% for small group and 85% for large group, and insurers below it owe rebates to employers and members. A carrier's blended MLR can be above the minimum while one of its companies still owes a rebate. Self-funded and level-funded plans aren't included. "Small group" is generally 1–50 employees (1–100 in CA, CO, NY and VT). Some California HMOs that report to the state instead may be missing. Source: CMS MLR public use file.
Top medical carriers among Form 5500 filers
- UnitedHealthcare 191
- Quartz Health Benefit Plans 104
- Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans) 94
- Dean Health Plan 65
- Compcare Health Services Insurance 32
- Group Health Cooperative of South Central Wisconsin 29
- Kaiser Permanente 21
- Cigna 21
- Security Health Plan of Wisconsin 15
- Medica Insurance 10
Employers where the carrier is the largest medical carrier.
Top brokers
- Insurance Solutions 254
- USI Insurance Services 108
- Cottingham & Butler 80
- Brown & Brown 79
- Marsh McLennan Agency 70
- Gallagher 59
- R and R Insurance Services 59
- Lockton 46
- Hausmann Group 45
- Risk Strategies 42
Employers where the firm is the main broker. Firms only.
Medical funding
- Self-funded 689 (43%)
- Fully insured 591 (37%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 148 (9%)
- No medical reported 134 (8%)
- Unknown 18 (1%)
- Mixed 6 (0%)
Renewal months
- Jan 1,261
- Feb 14
- Mar 17
- Apr 39
- May 26
- Jun 41
- Jul 50
- Aug 19
- Sep 30
- Oct 49
- Nov 19
- Dec 21
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kohl's Department Stores, Inc. Menomonee Falls, WI | 99,009 | Self-funded | Jan | $16.1M |
| Advocate Aurora Health, Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 85,571 | Self-funded | Jan | $51.5M |
| Manpowergroup Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 63,679 | Self-funded | Jan | $10.2M |
| Kwik Trip, Inc. LA Crosse, WI | 34,045 | Self-funded | Oct | $16.7M |
| Fiserv Solutions, LLC Milwaukee, WI | 22,527 | Self-funded | Jan | $25.8M |
| American Builders & Contractors Supply Co., Inc. Beloit, WI | 19,207 | Self-funded | Jul | $12.0M |
| Johnson Controls, Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 19,177 | Self-funded | Jan | $121M |
| Bellin Gundersen Health System, Inc. Green Bay, WI | 16,505 | Self-funded | Jan | $13.8M |
| Oshkosh Corporation Oshkosh, WI | 16,010 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.1M |
| Schneider National, Inc. Green Bay, WI | 14,878 | Self-funded | Jan | $6.0M |
| Epic Systems Corporation Verona, WI | 14,821 | Fully insured | Apr | $146M |
| Ashley Furniture Industries, LLC Arcadia, WI | 14,746 | Self-funded | Jan | $20.2M |
| Froedtert Thedacare Health, Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 14,403 | Self-funded | Jan | $16.6M |
| Menard, Inc. EAU Claire, WI | 13,910 | Fully insured | Jan | $114M |
| Komatsu Mining Corp. Milwaukee, WI | 13,019 | Self-funded | Jan | $6.9M |
| Amcor Flexibles North America, Inc. Oshkosh, WI | 11,923 | Self-funded | Jan | $17.8M |
| Kimberly-clark Corporation Neenah, WI | 11,661 | Self-funded | Jan | $21.9M |
| Northwestern Mutual Field Associations Milwaukee, WI | 11,113 | Fully insured | Jan | $170M |
| Kohler Co. & Subsidiaries Kohler, WI | 11,019 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.7M |
| American Family Mutual Insurance Company, S.I. Madison, WI | 10,453 | Fully insured | Jan | $32.3M |
| Aspirus Inc. Wausau, WI | 10,424 | Self-funded | Jan | $6.9M |
| Marshfield Clinic Health System, Inc. Marshfield, WI | 9,890 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Apr | $5.8M |
| Uline, Inc. Pleasant Prairie, WI | 8,666 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Oct | $4.6M |
| Case New Holland Industrial Inc. Racine, WI | 8,599 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.1M |
| Northwestern Mutual Life Ins.co. Milwaukee, WI | 8,369 | Self-funded | Jan | $36.0M |
| Quad/graphics, Inc. Sussex, WI | 8,080 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $8.0M |
| Saputo Cheese USA Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 7,962 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.6M |
| Rockwell Automation, Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 7,817 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $8.5M |
| Packers Holdings, LLC Kieler, WI | 7,617 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.2M |
| Regal Rexnord Corporation Milwaukee, WI | 7,542 | Self-funded | Jan | $13.2M |
| WEC Energy Group, Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 7,122 | Self-funded | Jan | $23.1M |
| Green Bay Packaging, Inc. Green Bay, WI | 7,016 | Self-funded | Jan | $6.6M |
| Schreiber Foods, Inc. Green Bay, WI | 6,952 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.3M |
| Molson Coors Beverage Company USA LLC Milwaukee, WI | 6,933 | Self-funded | Jan | $39.4M |
| Children's Hospital and Health System, Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 6,906 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.4M |
| Exact Sciences Corporation Madison, WI | 6,780 | Self-funded | Jan | $14.1M |
| Thedacare Inc. Neenah, WI | 6,507 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.5M |
| The Medical College of Wisconsin, Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 6,455 | Self-funded | Jan | $6.1M |
| Sentry Insurance Company Stevens Point, WI | 6,343 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.3M |
| Snap-on Incorporated Kenosha, WI | 5,920 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.5M |
| Generac Power Systems, Inc. Waukesha, WI | 5,598 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.7M |
| Kerry Inc. Beloit, WI | 5,591 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.9M |
| REV Group Inc Brookfield, WI | 5,551 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.9M |
| U.S. Venture, Inc. Appleton, WI | 5,417 | Self-funded | Jan | $7.0M |
| Clarios, LLC Glendale, WI | 5,416 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.5M |
| Molson Coors Beverage Company Milwaukee, WI | 5,263 | No medical reported | Jan | — |
| Robert W. Baird & Co., Inc. Milwaukee, WI | 5,228 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.2M |
| Michels Corporation Brownsville, WI | 5,218 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.3M |
| A. O. Smith Corporation Group Insurance Plan Milwaukee, WI | 4,920 | Self-funded | Jan | $7.3M |
| Greenheck FAN Corporation Schofield, WI | 4,754 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.5M |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.