Employee benefits in Ohio
2,758 employers in Ohio file a Form 5500 for health and welfare plans, covering 3,233,128 participants. The most common medical carriers are Anthem / Elevance, UnitedHealthcare, Cigna, and the most common brokers are USI Insurance Services, Gallagher, HUB International. Median broker compensation is 6.8% of premium.
Fully insured group health market share, MLR and rebates (2024)
Small group · $1.1B premium · 113,454 covered lives · 8 carriers · $18.0M in rebates owed
| Carrier | Premium | Covered lives | Share | MLR (3-yr) | Rebate owed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medical Mutual | $484M | 48,520 | 45% | 80% | — |
| Anthem / Elevance | $389M | 43,994 | 36% | 76% | $13.1M |
| UnitedHealthcare | $117M | 11,691 | 11% | 81% | $2.5M |
| Aultcare Insurance | $39.1M | 5,086 | 3.7% | 85% | — |
| Summacare | $27.5M | 3,372 | 2.6% | 72% | $2.3M |
| THP Insurance | $4.8M | 514 | 0.4% | 105% | — |
| Humana | $4.6M | 0 | 0.4% | 79% | $39K |
| Aetna | $2.3M | 277 | 0.2% | — | — |
Large group · $6.2B premium · 837,506 covered lives · 13 carriers · $87K in rebates owed
| Carrier | Premium | Covered lives | Share | MLR (3-yr) | Rebate owed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anthem / Elevance | $3.2B | 402,422 | 52% | 90% | — |
| Medical Mutual | $1.3B | 180,494 | 22% | 90% | — |
| UnitedHealthcare | $776M | 135,262 | 13% | 88% | — |
| Aetna | $358M | 48,376 | 5.8% | 89% | — |
| Cigna | $264M | 34,813 | 4.3% | 91% | — |
| Aultcare Insurance | $100M | 18,885 | 1.6% | 100% | — |
| Summacare | $44.0M | 6,375 | 0.7% | 90% | — |
| Sidecar Health Insurance | $43.1M | 7,917 | 0.7% | 93% | — |
| THP Insurance | $10.0M | 933 | 0.2% | 104% | — |
| Humana | $8.8M | 0 | 0.1% | 86% | — |
Fully insured comprehensive medical only, from insurers' 2024 Medical Loss Ratio reports to CMS (published about two years later). MLR is the official 3-year, credibility-adjusted share of premium spent on claims and quality improvement (2022–2024); the federal minimum is 80% for small group and 85% for large group, and insurers below it owe rebates to employers and members. A carrier's blended MLR can be above the minimum while one of its companies still owes a rebate. Self-funded and level-funded plans aren't included. "Small group" is generally 1–50 employees (1–100 in CA, CO, NY and VT). Some California HMOs that report to the state instead may be missing. Source: CMS MLR public use file.
Top medical carriers among Form 5500 filers
- Anthem / Elevance 358
- UnitedHealthcare 201
- Cigna 140
- Medical Mutual 137
- Medical Mutual of Ohio 116
- Aetna 64
- Kaiser Permanente 46
- Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans) 28
- Aultcare Insurance 23
- Sidecar Health Insurance 19
Employers where the carrier is the largest medical carrier.
Top brokers
- USI Insurance Services 315
- Gallagher 171
- HUB International 134
- McGohan Brabender Agency 105
- Hylant 104
- Marsh McLennan Agency 86
- Lockton 77
- OneDigital 73
- AssuredPartners 54
- Huntington Insurance 47
Employers where the firm is the main broker. Firms only.
Medical funding
- Self-funded 1,124 (41%)
- Fully insured 1,036 (38%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 359 (13%)
- No medical reported 167 (6%)
- Unknown 50 (2%)
- Mixed 22 (1%)
Renewal months
- Jan 1,969
- Feb 39
- Mar 47
- Apr 91
- May 73
- Jun 60
- Jul 204
- Aug 55
- Sep 47
- Oct 100
- Nov 46
- Dec 27
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Kroger Co. Cincinnati, OH | 320,385 | Self-funded | Jan | $229M |
| The Procter & Gamble Company Cincinnati, OH | 109,000 | Self-funded | Jan | $30.8M |
| Eaton Corporation Cleveland, OH | 96,940 | Self-funded | Jan | $13.9M |
| Macys, Inc. Springdale, OH | 93,959 | Fully insured | Jul | $346M |
| L Brands Service Company, LLC Columbus, OH | 76,340 | Self-funded | Jan | $9.1M |
| The Progressive Corporation Mayfield Village, OH | 69,976 | Self-funded | Jan | $59.9M |
| The Cleveland Clinic Foundation Cleveland, OH | 65,297 | Self-funded | Jan | $48.4M |
| First Student, Inc. Cincinnati, OH | 50,777 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $24.8M |
| Abercrombie & Fitch Co. New Albany, OH | 49,048 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $2.5M |
| The Sherwin-williams Company Cleveland, OH | 46,813 | Self-funded | Jan | $43.9M |
| Cintas Corporation Mason, OH | 44,877 | Self-funded | Jan | $38.3M |
| BON Secours Mercy Health, Inc. Blue ASH, OH | 40,961 | Self-funded | Jan | $25.8M |
| VS Service Company, LLC Reynoldsburg, OH | 40,729 | Self-funded | Jan | $6.1M |
| Exel Inc. Westerville, OH | 37,213 | Self-funded | Jan | $16.2M |
| Cardinal Health, Inc. Dublin, OH | 35,221 | Self-funded | Jan | $39.7M |
| Nestle USA, Inc. Attn Health & Welfare Solon, OH | 34,737 | Self-funded | Jan | $55.0M |
| General Electric Company, Operating As GE Aerospace Evendale, OH | 31,632 | Self-funded | Jan | $109M |
| American Honda Motor Co., Inc. Marysville, OH | 30,643 | Self-funded | Jan | $44.3M |
| University Hospitals Health System Shaker Heights, OH | 28,444 | Self-funded | Jan | $18.1M |
| Parker Hannifin Corporation Cleveland, OH | 27,288 | Self-funded | Jul | $29.9M |
| Ohiohealth Corporation Columbus, OH | 27,244 | Self-funded | Jan | $31.3M |
| Kroger Texas, L.P. Cincinnati, OH | 26,194 | Self-funded | Jan | — |
| The Goodyear Tire & Rubber Company Akron, OH | 21,942 | Self-funded | Jan | $82.2M |
| Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company Columbus, OH | 21,940 | Self-funded | Jan | $34.8M |
| Huntington Bancshares Incorporated Columbus, OH | 20,290 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $20.0M |
| Fifth Third Bancorp Cincinnati, OH | 19,226 | Self-funded | Jan | $36.4M |
| Marathon Petroleum Company LP Findlay, OH | 18,574 | Self-funded | Jan | $44.5M |
| Owens Corning Toledo, OH | 18,385 | Self-funded | Jan | $20.0M |
| Keycorp Cleveland, OH | 18,118 | Self-funded | Jan | $13.4M |
| R & L Carriers, Inc. Wilmington, OH | 18,049 | Self-funded | Jan | $29.1M |
| Cincinnati Childrens Hospital Medical Center Cincinnati, OH | 17,985 | Self-funded | Jul | $13.9M |
| American Electric Power Service Corporation Columbus, OH | 17,455 | Self-funded | Jan | $58.4M |
| TA Operating LLC Westlake, OH | 17,453 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $5.6M |
| First Source Employee Management North Olmsted, OH | 17,449 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $3.0M |
| Promedica Health System, Inc. Toledo, OH | 15,798 | Self-funded | Jan | $16.5M |
| Bob Evans Restaurants, LLC New Albany, OH | 14,426 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.6M |
| The Davey Tree Expert Company Kent, OH | 14,372 | Self-funded | Jan | — |
| Nationwide Children's Hospital Columbus, OH | 14,215 | Self-funded | Jan | $10.2M |
| Safelite Group, Inc. Columbus, OH | 14,128 | Self-funded | Jan | $26.0M |
| Safelite Group, Inc. Columbus, OH | 14,103 | Self-funded | Jan | $26.6M |
| Crosscountry Mortgage LLC Cleveland, OH | 13,995 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.4M |
| Staffmark Group, LLC Cincinnati, OH | 13,492 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.9M |
| Crown Equipment Corporation New Bremen, OH | 13,431 | Fully insured | Jan | $171M |
| The Wendy's Company Dublin, OH | 13,394 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.3M |
| Concentrix CVG Corporation Cincinnati, OH | 13,120 | Self-funded | Jan | $20.6M |
| Sterling Jewelers Inc. Akron, OH | 12,860 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.3M |
| Health Care Facilities Staffing, LLC Cincinnati, OH | 11,597 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $12.7M |
| Premier Health Dayton, OH | 11,558 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $10.9M |
| Designer Brands, Inc. Columbus, OH | 11,501 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.4M |
| Trihealth, Inc. Cincinnati, OH | 11,229 | Self-funded | Jan | $8.7M |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.