McGohan Brabender Agency
Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings
McGohan Brabender Agency is the broker of record for 170 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 52,707 participants, most in OH, IN, KY. Commissions and fees average 5.2% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 9 and lost 2 broker-of-record relationships.
Employers
170
Participants
52,707
Premium placed
$129M
Commissions + fees
$6.7M
Comp rate
5.2%
Where the book is
Carriers on this book
- Anthem / Elevance 33
- The Hartford 32
- EyeMed / Fidelity Security Life 29
- The Standard 20
- Unum / Colonial 20
- Guardian 19
- Superior Dental Care 18
- Principal 17
- Delta Dental 15
- Lincoln Financial 13
Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.
Group size and funding
- 0–49 participants 5
- 50–99 participants 9
- 100–249 participants 94
- 250–499 participants 31
- 500–999 participants 24
- 1,000–4,999 participants 7
- Self-funded 88 (52%)
- Fully insured 60 (35%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 11 (6%)
- No medical reported 6 (4%)
- Unknown 4 (2%)
- Mixed 1 (1%)
Recent wins (9)
| Employer | Previous broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Otterbein University Westerville, OH | Milestone Benefits Agency | 2025 |
| Environmental Management Service Plain City, OH | France and Associates | 2025 |
| Beaumont Home Health & Hospice Troy, MI | Brower Insurance | 2025 |
| Miles McClellan Construction Company Columbus, OH | RX Benefits | 2025 |
| Instantwhip Foods, Inc. Columbus, OH | Hylant | 2025 |
| Fratco, Inc. Monticello, IN | Horton Group | 2025 |
| Hawkstone Associates, Inc. DBA Triumph Energy Harrison, OH | Energy Insurance Agency | 2025 |
| Classic Carriers, Inc. Versailles, OH | HDH Group | 2025 |
| Furlong Enterprises, Inc. Greenville, OH | Phelan Insurance Agency | 2025 |
Recent losses (2)
| Employer | New broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Community Health & Wellness Partners Bellefontaine, OH | Hylant | 2024 |
| Day Air Credit Union, Inc. Kettering, OH | Gallagher | 2025 |
A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| University of Dayton Dayton, OH | 2,832 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.2M |
| Cooper Hatchery, Inc. Fort Recovery, OH | 1,823 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $2.3M |
| Jeff Wyler Automotive Family, Inc. Milford, OH | 1,619 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Mar | $2.8M |
| Mountain Comprehensive Care Center, Inc Prestonsburg, KY | 1,543 | Self-funded | Jul | $1.0M |
| Cedarville University Cedarville, OH | 1,219 | Self-funded | Jan | $768K |
| Fortis Solutions Group, LLC Virginia Beach, VA | 1,062 | Self-funded | Jul | $1.2M |
| Ohio's Hospice, Inc. Dayton, OH | 1,059 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.9M |
| The Shepherd Material Science Company Cincinnati, OH | 926 | Self-funded | Jan | $443K |
| Superior Environmental Solutions, Inc. West Chester, OH | 925 | Self-funded | Jan | $716K |
| Henny Penny Corporation Eaton, OH | 898 | Self-funded | Jan | $536K |
| Divisions, Inc. Cincinnati, OH | 867 | Self-funded | Jan | $755K |
| Danis Building Construction Company Miamisburg, OH | 832 | Mixed | Jan | $979K |
| Eduvision Inc., DBA Arizona College Phoenix, AZ | 813 | Self-funded | Jan | $576K |
| Kalmbach Feeds, Inc. Upper Sandusky, OH | 785 | Self-funded | Jan | $412K |
| Goodwill Industries of Central Ohio Columbus, OH | 741 | Fully insured | Jan | $3.7M |
| Spectrum Control, Inc. Fairview, PA | 707 | Fully insured | Jan | $8.3M |
| Gardens Alive Lawrenceburg, IN | 700 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $2.1M |
| United Federal Credit Union St. Joseph, MI | 680 | Self-funded | Jan | $451K |
| Baxters North America, Inc. Blue ASH, OH | 645 | Self-funded | Jan | $742K |
| NX Automotive Logistics USA, Inc. East Liberty, OH | 643 | Self-funded | Jan | $995K |
| Dayton Progress Corporation Dayton, OH | 600 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $1.2M |
| Alternate Solutions Healthcare System, Inc. Kettering, OH | 590 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.6M |
| Formica Corporation Cincinnati, OH | 589 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.2M |
| Gosiger, Inc. Dayton, OH | 589 | Self-funded | Jul | $805K |
| Accelevation Springboro, OH | 582 | Fully insured | Sep | $2.2M |
| Caldwell Tanks, Inc & Preload, LLC Louisville, KY | 558 | Self-funded | Jan | $540K |
| Sutphen Corporation Dublin, OH | 537 | Self-funded | Jan | $616K |
| Meridian Bioscience, Inc. Cincinnati, OH | 532 | Self-funded | Jan | $701K |
| Takumi Stamping Inc. Fairfield, OH | 514 | Self-funded | Jan | $480K |
| Ashland University Ashland, OH | 512 | Self-funded | Jan | $502K |
| Southeastern Equipment Co. Inc Cambridge, OH | 504 | Self-funded | Jan | $216K |
| Neaton Auto Products MFG., Inc. Eaton, OH | 497 | Self-funded | Feb | $243K |
| Modern Aviation, Inc. Amarillo, TX | 440 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.9M |
| Alliance Industries, Inc. Marietta, OH | 440 | Self-funded | Jan | $170K |
| Thompson Concrete Holdings, Inc. Carroll, OH | 420 | Self-funded | Jan | $203K |
| Leadwise, Inc. Miamisburg, OH | 415 | Self-funded | Jan | $808K |
| Columbus Center for Human Services, Inc. Columbus, OH | 403 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.8M |
| Donatos Pizzeria LLC Columbus, OH | 375 | Fully insured | Jan | $4.2M |
| Otterbein University Westerville, OH | 363 | Self-funded | Jan | $218K |
| Setzer Corporation Dayton, OH | 353 | Fully insured | Jan | $4.1M |
| Feintool U.S. Operations Inc. Blue ASH, OH | 352 | Self-funded | Mar | $442K |
| Jeff Schmitt Auto Group, Inc Fairborn, OH | 344 | Self-funded | Jan | $252K |
| The Loeb Electric Company Columbus, OH | 331 | Self-funded | Apr | $285K |
| Lakeview Farms, LLC Delphos, OH | 323 | Fully insured | Jan | $7.9M |
| Ohio Northern University ADA, OH | 322 | Self-funded | Jan | $440K |
| Jane Pauley Community Health Center Indianapolis, IN | 319 | Fully insured | Jun | $4.7M |
| CK Construction Group Inc. Westerville, OH | 317 | No medical reported | Jan | $134K |
| Dayton-phoenix Group, Inc. Dayton, OH | 314 | Self-funded | Jan | $310K |
| Frontier Technology Inc. Beavercreek Township, OH | 307 | Fully insured | Jan | $4.3M |
| General Tool Company Inc Cincinnati, OH | 295 | Fully insured | Jan | $565K |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.