Medical Mutual

Insurance carrier · group business from Form 5500 filings

Medical Mutual insures 186 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, mostly Medical, Rx, Vision, Dental, with $323M of reported premium. Median broker compensation on its contracts is 3.2% of premium.

Employers
186
Premium
$323M
Covered lives
31,439
Median comp rate
3.2%

Lines of coverage

Number of contracts by line.

Top states

Brokers placing this carrier

Number of employers. Firms only; individual agents aren't listed.

Medical funding of its employers

Fully insured group health market share, MLR and rebates by state (2024)

Nationally: $487M small-group premium (48,956 covered lives) and $1.3B large-group (181,356 lives).

StateSmall group shareLarge group share
OH45%
#1 · $484M · MLR 80%
22%
#2 · $1.3B · MLR 90%
MI0.1%
#8 · $2.1M
0.1%
#10 · $4.5M · MLR 116%

Fully insured comprehensive medical only, from insurers' 2024 Medical Loss Ratio reports to CMS (published about two years later). MLR is the official 3-year, credibility-adjusted share of premium spent on claims and quality improvement (2022–2024); the federal minimum is 80% for small group and 85% for large group, and insurers below it owe rebates to employers and members. A carrier's blended MLR can be above the minimum while one of its companies still owes a rebate. Self-funded and level-funded plans aren't included. "Small group" is generally 1–50 employees (1–100 in CA, CO, NY and VT). Some California HMOs that report to the state instead may be missing. Source: CMS MLR public use file.

Largest employers by premium with this carrier

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
Macys, Inc.
Springdale, OH
93,959Fully insuredJul$346M
Hattie Larlham Center for Children With Disabilities
Mantua, OH
429Fully insuredJan$7.9M
The NRP Investments LLC
Cleveland, OH
1,059Fully insuredJul$9.0M
Quadax, Inc.
Beachwood, OH
662Fully insuredJan$8.0M
Starbucks Corporation
Seattle, WA
219,580Fully insuredOct$775M
JTM Provision Company, Inc.
Harrison, OH
456Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$8.2M
Ohio Education Association
Columbus, OH
181Fully insuredJan$6.3M
Ranpak Corp
Concord Township, OH
321Fully insuredJan$6.2M
First Mutual Holding Co.
Lakewood, OH
432Fully insuredJan$6.1M
Anderson Dubose, Inc
Lordstown, OH
294Fully insuredOct$5.8M
Minute MEN, Inc.
Cleveland, OH
190Fully insuredJan$4.9M
Step Forward
Cleveland, OH
306Fully insuredJan$4.7M
Axess Family Services, Inc.
Ravenna, OH
305Fully insuredSep$4.6M
Norman Noble, Inc.
Highland Heights, OH
603Fully insuredJan$5.0M
Wiley Organics, Inc.
Coshocton, OH
206Fully insuredMar$4.6M
MGM Resorts International
LAS Vegas, NV
26,547Self-fundedJan$64.8M
A. J. Rose Manufacturing Co.
Avon, OH
274Fully insuredJan$4.4M
SG Chevrolet LLC
Strongsville, OH
178Fully insuredJan$3.7M
Area Energy & Electric, Inc.
Sidney, OH
421Fully insuredJan$3.7M
Gardiner Service Company
Solon, OH
253Fully insuredJan$3.7M
Northern Stamping, Inc.
Valley View, OH
253Fully insuredJan$3.8M
Hospital Service Associates, Inc. DBA APS Medical Billing
Toledo, OH
283Fully insuredJan$3.4M
CT Consultants
Mentor, OH
258Fully insuredJan$3.5M
West Central Ohio Group Ltd
Lima, OH
140Fully insuredJan$3.4M
Saint Ignatius High School
Cleveland, OH
195Fully insuredJan$3.4M
Child Development Council of Franklin County, Inc.
Columbus, OH
278Fully insuredJan$3.6M
MIM Software, Inc.
Cleveland, OH
0Fully insuredJan$3.4M
Area Agency on Aging District 7
Jackson, OH
167Fully insuredJan$3.0M
Darden Restaurants, Inc.
Orlando, FL
22,533Fully insuredJan$397M
TFO Tech Company, Ltd.
Jeffersonville, OH
133Fully insuredJul$2.9M
Struktol Company of America, LLC
Stow, OH
131Fully insuredJan$2.9M
ARC Industries, Incorporated, of Franklin County, Ohio
Columbus, OH
225Fully insuredJan$3.0M
The Columbus Academy
Columbus, OH
214Fully insuredJan$2.8M
Atlantic Tool & DIE, Inc.
Strongsville, OH
282Fully insuredJan$2.6M
Budget Dumpster, LLC
Westlake, OH
317Fully insuredJan$2.7M
Westfield Bank
Seville, OH
0Fully insuredJan$2.7M
Gifthealth, Inc.
Columbus, OH
190Fully insuredJan$2.8M
Greater Cleveland Food Bank
Cleveland, OH
172Fully insuredJan$2.8M
Auto Systems Center, Inc.
Toledo, OH
0Fully insuredJan$2.7M
Geis Construction, Inc.
Streetsboro, OH
194Fully insuredJan$2.7M
Voss Auto Network, Inc.
Centerville, OH
398Fully insuredJan$2.8M
Charles C Ungurean
Coshocton, OH
180Fully insuredJan$2.6M
North Central Mental Health Services Inc
Columbus, OH
160Fully insuredJan$2.6M
Integrated Mill Systems, Inc.
Willoughby, OH
127Fully insuredJul$2.7M
F&G Tool & DIE Company
Dayton, OH
110Fully insuredMar$2.5M
Custom Agri Systems, Inc.
Napoleon, OH
213Fully insuredJan$2.6M
Electronic Merchant Systems
Cleveland, OH
182Fully insuredJul$2.5M
Marous Brothers Construction, Inc.
Willoughby, OH
134Fully insuredJan$2.4M
Bird Technologies Group
Solon, OH
168Fully insuredOct$2.5M
Wilmer Cutler Pickering Hale and Dorr LLP
Boston, MA
1,796Fully insuredJan$11.0M

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.