Otterbein University

1 S Grove St, Westerville, OH 43081
Education (NAICS 611000) · EIN 31-4379532
2025 plan yearSelf-funded

Otterbein University (Westerville, OH, 363 participants) has a self-funded health plan. Its broker of record is McGohan Brabender Agency, paid 1.6% of reported premium (median for this size: 3.6%). The broker of record changed in plan year 2025; in 2024 it was Milestone Benefits Agency. Coverage renews in January.

Participants
363
Renews
Jan
Schedule A premium
$218K
Broker comp
$3,411
Comp rate
1.6%

Carriers by line

Insurance contracts (Schedule A)

LinesCarrierPolicy yearCoveredPremiumPer covered / moBroker compComp ratePaid to
AD&D, LTD, Life
AD&D
American United Life InsuranceJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
362$159,795 $37
median $39
$3,4112.1%
below typical · median 15%
McGohan Brabender Agency
Vision VSPJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
261$51,562 $16
median $21
$00.0% None listed
EAP
EAP
Impact SolutionsJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
377$6,967 $2
median $33
$00.0% None listed

Brokers and agents paid

FirmTypeLocationContractsCommissions + fees
McGohan Brabender AgencyInsurance agent or brokerDayton, OH1$3,411

Plan-year history, 2019–2025

$269K 2019 $792K 2020 $687K 2021 $257K 2022 $199K 2023 $203K 2024 $218K 2025 ●
Schedule A premium by plan year · ● broker of record changed. Source: Form 5500.
Plan yearParticipantsPremiumBroker compMedical fundingTop carriersBrokers
2025363$218K$3,411 Self-fundedAmerican United Life Insurance, VSP, Impact Solutions McGohan Brabender Agency
Broker of record changed (was Milestone Benefits Agency in 2024)
2024368$203K$0 Self-fundedThe Standard, VSP, Anthem / Elevance Milestone Benefits Agency
2023364$199K$0 Self-fundedAnthem / Elevance, VSP None listed
2022395$257K$0 Self-fundedAnthem / Elevance, Unum / Colonial, VSP None listed
2021381$687K$21K Self-funded (stop-loss)HCC Life Insurance, Anthem / Elevance, VSP Centerstone Insurance and FIN Services
2020405$792K$0 Self-funded (stop-loss)Anthem / Elevance, VSP, Unum / Colonial None listed
2019440$269K$-483 Self-fundedAnthem / Elevance, VSP, Unum / Colonial USI Insurance Services

Across all of this employer's welfare plans, as filed. Years with missing or partial filings show smaller totals.

Health and welfare plans

Plan #PlanPlan yearParticipantsBenefitsFundingReceivedOriginal
505Otterbein University Employee Benefits PlanJan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025363Health, Life, Dental, Vision, Long-term disability, OtherInsurance + General assetsOct 8, 2026Filing PDF

Data as filed with the U.S. Department of Labor, through Oct 24, 2026. Something wrong? Report a data issue.