Employee benefits in Indiana
1,401 employers in Indiana file a Form 5500 for health and welfare plans, covering 948,402 participants. The most common medical carriers are Anthem / Elevance, UnitedHealthcare, Cigna, and the most common brokers are MJ Insurance, Hylant, Gibson Insurance Agency. Median broker compensation is 11% of premium.
Fully insured group health market share, MLR and rebates (2024)
Small group · $737M premium · 81,030 covered lives · 8 carriers · $25.7M in rebates owed
| Carrier | Premium | Covered lives | Share | MLR (3-yr) | Rebate owed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anthem / Elevance | $508M | 56,170 | 69% | 75% | $21.5M |
| UnitedHealthcare | $127M | 11,761 | 17% | 77% | $4.2M |
| Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana | $67.3M | 7,983 | 9.1% | 89% | — |
| IU Health Plan | $15.2M | 2,991 | 2.1% | 105% | — |
| Siho | $13.2M | 1,882 | 1.8% | 98% | — |
| Humana | $4.2M | 0 | 0.6% | 83% | — |
| Aetna | $1.5M | 105 | 0.2% | — | — |
| Integon National Insurance Company | $868K | 138 | 0.1% | — | — |
Large group · $2.4B premium · 304,901 covered lives · 13 carriers · $354K in rebates owed
| Carrier | Premium | Covered lives | Share | MLR (3-yr) | Rebate owed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Anthem / Elevance | $1.7B | 217,781 | 73% | 88% | — |
| UnitedHealthcare | $358M | 48,208 | 15% | 85% | $352K |
| Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana | $98.3M | 15,575 | 4.2% | 98% | — |
| IU Health Plan | $48.3M | 6,646 | 2.1% | 85% | — |
| Cigna | $42.8M | 6,361 | 1.8% | 97% | — |
| Aetna | $35.4M | 4,901 | 1.5% | 94% | — |
| Siho | $33.2M | 4,397 | 1.4% | 95% | — |
| Humana | $6.3M | 0 | 0.3% | 92% | — |
| Nippon Life Insurance | $2.2M | 292 | 0.1% | — | — |
| SHELTER Insurance Group | $473K | 73 | 0.0% | — | — |
Fully insured comprehensive medical only, from insurers' 2024 Medical Loss Ratio reports to CMS (published about two years later). MLR is the official 3-year, credibility-adjusted share of premium spent on claims and quality improvement (2022–2024); the federal minimum is 80% for small group and 85% for large group, and insurers below it owe rebates to employers and members. A carrier's blended MLR can be above the minimum while one of its companies still owes a rebate. Self-funded and level-funded plans aren't included. "Small group" is generally 1–50 employees (1–100 in CA, CO, NY and VT). Some California HMOs that report to the state instead may be missing. Source: CMS MLR public use file.
Top medical carriers among Form 5500 filers
- Anthem / Elevance 171
- UnitedHealthcare 79
- Cigna 48
- Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana 17
- Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans) 15
- Kaiser Permanente 9
- Aetna 9
- Healthjoy 8
- HCC Life Insurance 7
- Companion Life Insurance 5
Employers where the carrier is the largest medical carrier.
Top brokers
- MJ Insurance 78
- Hylant 76
- Gibson Insurance Agency 72
- Gallagher 55
- Apex Benefits Group 53
- USI Insurance Services 47
- AssuredPartners 46
- Marsh McLennan Agency 44
- Locascio Hadden and Dennis 43
- Lockton 36
Employers where the firm is the main broker. Firms only.
Medical funding
- Self-funded 735 (52%)
- Fully insured 342 (24%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 151 (11%)
- No medical reported 135 (10%)
- Unknown 31 (2%)
- Mixed 7 (0%)
Renewal months
- Jan 1,013
- Feb 20
- Mar 34
- Apr 37
- May 51
- Jun 30
- Jul 65
- Aug 34
- Sep 28
- Oct 51
- Nov 18
- Dec 20
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ATH Holding Company LLC Indianapolis, IN | 66,832 | Self-funded | Jan | $119M |
| Indiana University Health Inc. Indianapolis, IN | 35,830 | Self-funded | Jan | $38.9M |
| Cummins Inc Columbus, IN | 29,310 | Self-funded | Jan | $27.9M |
| ELI Lilly and Company Indianapolis, IN | 25,405 | Self-funded | Jan | $22.8M |
| Parkview Health System, Inc Fort Wayne, IN | 17,557 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.7M |
| Berry Global, Inc. (FKA Berry Plastics Corporation) Evansville, IN | 15,084 | Self-funded | Jan | $17.5M |
| Toyota Industries North America, Inc. Columbus, IN | 15,033 | Self-funded | Jan | $23.1M |
| Community Health Network, Inc. Indianapolis, IN | 14,953 | Self-funded | Jan | $26.3M |
| Usic, LLC Indianapolis, IN | 12,096 | Self-funded | Jan | $7.3M |
| Deaconess Health System Evansville, IN | 11,125 | Self-funded | Oct | $16.1M |
| Hospital Employee Benefit Assoc. Trust Carmel, IN | 10,515 | No medical reported | Oct | $5.3M |
| Lippert Components Inc. Elkhart, IN | 10,510 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $14.5M |
| Forest River, Inc. Elkhart, IN | 10,475 | Self-funded | Jan | $9.8M |
| Steel Dynamics, Inc. Fort Wayne, IN | 10,419 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $13.6M |
| Thor Industries, Inc. Elkhart, IN | 9,896 | Self-funded | Jan | $13.0M |
| Masterbrand, Inc. Jasper, IN | 9,333 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.2M |
| Onemain General Services Corporation Evansville, IN | 9,190 | Self-funded | Jan | $17.4M |
| Beacon Health System South Bend, IN | 8,731 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.3M |
| Aisin Holdings of America, Inc. Seymour, IN | 8,560 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $12.5M |
| Patrick Industries, Inc. Elkhart, IN | 8,329 | Fully insured | Jan | $49.9M |
| Cook Group Incorporated Bloomington, IN | 7,818 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $16.1M |
| Nisource Inc. Merrillville, IN | 7,742 | Self-funded | Jan | $22.8M |
| Zimmer Biomet Holdings, Inc. Warsaw, IN | 7,332 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $10.3M |
| American Senior Communities, L.L.C. Indianapolis, IN | 7,035 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $6.4M |
| Republic Airways Holdings Inc. Carmel, IN | 6,503 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.2M |
| University of Notre Dame DU LAC Notre Dame, IN | 6,434 | Self-funded | Jan | $12.0M |
| Republic Airways Holdings Inc. Indianapolis, IN | 6,295 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.7M |
| Subaru of Indiana Automotive, Inc. Lafayette, IN | 5,735 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.0M |
| Community Foundation of Northwest in, Inc. Munster, IN | 5,626 | No medical reported | Jan | $2.3M |
| Old National Bancorp Evansville, IN | 5,031 | Self-funded | Jan | $7.8M |
| White Lodging Services, Corp. Merrillville, IN | 4,929 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.7M |
| Wabash National Corporation Lafayette, IN | 4,872 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.7M |
| Crowe LLP South Bend, IN | 4,814 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $11.7M |
| The Finish Line, Inc. Indianapolis, IN | 4,616 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.3M |
| Powers Health Munster, IN | 4,604 | Self-funded | Jan | $5.2M |
| Hopebridge, LLC Carmel, IN | 4,385 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.6M |
| Schlage Lock Company LLC Carmel, IN | 4,364 | Self-funded | Jan | $7.2M |
| Jasper Holdings, Inc. Jasper, IN | 4,167 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.6M |
| Ardagh Glass Inc. Indianapolis, IN | 3,921 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.9M |
| Elevance Health Companies of Puerto Rico, LLC Indianapolis, IN | 3,645 | Fully insured | Jan | $10.9M |
| Trimedx Holdings, LLC Indianapolis, IN | 3,349 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.4M |
| CNO Services LLC Carmel, IN | 3,345 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.6M |
| Union Hospital Inc Terre Haute, IN | 3,338 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.6M |
| Aaag Holdings, Inc. Carmel, IN | 3,270 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.0M |
| Warehouse Services, Inc. Mount Vernon, IN | 2,960 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.4M |
| Priority Life Care, LLC Fort Wayne, IN | 2,958 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $2.9M |
| Ambassador Enterprises, LLC Fort Wayne, IN | 2,905 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.8M |
| Elanco US Inc. Greenfield, IN | 2,793 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.0M |
| Hillenbrand, Inc. Batesville, IN | 2,688 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.5M |
| Simon Property Group L.P Indianapolis, IN | 2,682 | Self-funded | Jan | $2.5M |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.