Employee benefits in Indiana

Health and welfare plans from Form 5500 filings

1,401 employers in Indiana file a Form 5500 for health and welfare plans, covering 948,402 participants. The most common medical carriers are Anthem / Elevance, UnitedHealthcare, Cigna, and the most common brokers are MJ Insurance, Hylant, Gibson Insurance Agency. Median broker compensation is 11% of premium.

Employers
1,401
Participants
948,402
Schedule A premium
$1.8B
Median comp rate
11%
Recent broker changes
69

Search employers in Open5500 →

Fully insured group health market share, MLR and rebates (2024)

Small group · $737M premium · 81,030 covered lives · 8 carriers · $25.7M in rebates owed

CarrierPremiumCovered livesShareMLR (3-yr)Rebate owed
Anthem / Elevance$508M56,17069%75%$21.5M
UnitedHealthcare$127M11,76117%77%$4.2M
Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana$67.3M7,9839.1%89%—
IU Health Plan$15.2M2,9912.1%105%—
Siho$13.2M1,8821.8%98%—
Humana$4.2M00.6%83%—
Aetna$1.5M1050.2%——
Integon National Insurance Company$868K1380.1%——

Large group · $2.4B premium · 304,901 covered lives · 13 carriers · $354K in rebates owed

CarrierPremiumCovered livesShareMLR (3-yr)Rebate owed
Anthem / Elevance$1.7B217,78173%88%—
UnitedHealthcare$358M48,20815%85%$352K
Physicians Health Plan of Northern Indiana$98.3M15,5754.2%98%—
IU Health Plan$48.3M6,6462.1%85%—
Cigna$42.8M6,3611.8%97%—
Aetna$35.4M4,9011.5%94%—
Siho$33.2M4,3971.4%95%—
Humana$6.3M00.3%92%—
Nippon Life Insurance$2.2M2920.1%——
SHELTER Insurance Group$473K730.0%——

Fully insured comprehensive medical only, from insurers' 2024 Medical Loss Ratio reports to CMS (published about two years later). MLR is the official 3-year, credibility-adjusted share of premium spent on claims and quality improvement (2022–2024); the federal minimum is 80% for small group and 85% for large group, and insurers below it owe rebates to employers and members. A carrier's blended MLR can be above the minimum while one of its companies still owes a rebate. Self-funded and level-funded plans aren't included. "Small group" is generally 1–50 employees (1–100 in CA, CO, NY and VT). Some California HMOs that report to the state instead may be missing. Source: CMS MLR public use file.

Top medical carriers among Form 5500 filers

Employers where the carrier is the largest medical carrier.

Top brokers

Employers where the firm is the main broker. Firms only.

Medical funding

Renewal months

Largest employers

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
ATH Holding Company LLC
Indianapolis, IN
66,832Self-fundedJan$119M
Indiana University Health Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
35,830Self-fundedJan$38.9M
Cummins Inc
Columbus, IN
29,310Self-fundedJan$27.9M
ELI Lilly and Company
Indianapolis, IN
25,405Self-fundedJan$22.8M
Parkview Health System, Inc
Fort Wayne, IN
17,557Self-fundedJan$12.7M
Berry Global, Inc. (FKA Berry Plastics Corporation)
Evansville, IN
15,084Self-fundedJan$17.5M
Toyota Industries North America, Inc.
Columbus, IN
15,033Self-fundedJan$23.1M
Community Health Network, Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
14,953Self-fundedJan$26.3M
Usic, LLC
Indianapolis, IN
12,096Self-fundedJan$7.3M
Deaconess Health System
Evansville, IN
11,125Self-fundedOct$16.1M
Hospital Employee Benefit Assoc. Trust
Carmel, IN
10,515No medical reportedOct$5.3M
Lippert Components Inc.
Elkhart, IN
10,510Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$14.5M
Forest River, Inc.
Elkhart, IN
10,475Self-fundedJan$9.8M
Steel Dynamics, Inc.
Fort Wayne, IN
10,419Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$13.6M
Thor Industries, Inc.
Elkhart, IN
9,896Self-fundedJan$13.0M
Masterbrand, Inc.
Jasper, IN
9,333Self-fundedJan$3.2M
Onemain General Services Corporation
Evansville, IN
9,190Self-fundedJan$17.4M
Beacon Health System
South Bend, IN
8,731Self-fundedJan$12.3M
Aisin Holdings of America, Inc.
Seymour, IN
8,560Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$12.5M
Patrick Industries, Inc.
Elkhart, IN
8,329Fully insuredJan$49.9M
Cook Group Incorporated
Bloomington, IN
7,818Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$16.1M
Nisource Inc.
Merrillville, IN
7,742Self-fundedJan$22.8M
Zimmer Biomet Holdings, Inc.
Warsaw, IN
7,332Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$10.3M
American Senior Communities, L.L.C.
Indianapolis, IN
7,035Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$6.4M
Republic Airways Holdings Inc.
Carmel, IN
6,503Self-fundedJan$4.2M
University of Notre Dame DU LAC
Notre Dame, IN
6,434Self-fundedJan$12.0M
Republic Airways Holdings Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
6,295Self-fundedJan$3.7M
Subaru of Indiana Automotive, Inc.
Lafayette, IN
5,735Self-fundedJan$5.0M
Community Foundation of Northwest in, Inc.
Munster, IN
5,626No medical reportedJan$2.3M
Old National Bancorp
Evansville, IN
5,031Self-fundedJan$7.8M
White Lodging Services, Corp.
Merrillville, IN
4,929Self-fundedJan$1.7M
Wabash National Corporation
Lafayette, IN
4,872Self-fundedJan$4.7M
Crowe LLP
South Bend, IN
4,814Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$11.7M
The Finish Line, Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
4,616Self-fundedJan$1.3M
Powers Health
Munster, IN
4,604Self-fundedJan$5.2M
Hopebridge, LLC
Carmel, IN
4,385Self-fundedJan$2.6M
Schlage Lock Company LLC
Carmel, IN
4,364Self-fundedJan$7.2M
Jasper Holdings, Inc.
Jasper, IN
4,167Self-fundedJan$2.6M
Ardagh Glass Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
3,921Self-fundedJan$2.9M
Elevance Health Companies of Puerto Rico, LLC
Indianapolis, IN
3,645Fully insuredJan$10.9M
Trimedx Holdings, LLC
Indianapolis, IN
3,349Self-fundedJan$3.4M
CNO Services LLC
Carmel, IN
3,345Self-fundedJan$4.6M
Union Hospital Inc
Terre Haute, IN
3,338Self-fundedJan$3.6M
Aaag Holdings, Inc.
Carmel, IN
3,270Self-fundedJan$2.0M
Warehouse Services, Inc.
Mount Vernon, IN
2,960Self-fundedJan$3.4M
Priority Life Care, LLC
Fort Wayne, IN
2,958Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$2.9M
Ambassador Enterprises, LLC
Fort Wayne, IN
2,905Self-fundedJan$1.8M
Elanco US Inc.
Greenfield, IN
2,793Self-fundedJan$3.0M
Hillenbrand, Inc.
Batesville, IN
2,688Self-fundedJan$2.5M
Simon Property Group L.P
Indianapolis, IN
2,682Self-fundedJan$2.5M

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.