Building Products Inc.

PO Box 1413, Watertown, SD 57201
Wholesale trade (NAICS 423300) · EIN 46-0250491
2025 plan yearFully insured

Building Products Inc. (Watertown, SD, 180 participants) has a fully insured health plan with Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans). Its brokers of record are Cottingham & Butler, Mitchell J Paeper and Heather Bramer, paid 0.7% of reported premium (median for this size: 4.4%). The broker of record changed in plan year 2025; in 2024 it was Freimark and Associates. Coverage renews in January.

Participants
180
Renews
Jan
Schedule A premium
$1.5M
Broker comp
$11K
Comp rate
0.7%

Carriers by line

Insurance contracts (Schedule A)

LinesCarrierPolicy yearCoveredPremiumPer covered / moBroker compComp ratePaid to
Rx, Medical Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans)Jan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
106$1,401,889
experience-rated
$1,102
median $598
$00.0% None listed
AD&D, LTD, STD, Life
AD&D
SymetraJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
180$50,878 $24
median $40
$5,96412%
typical · median 15%
Cottingham & Butler
STD AflacJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
54$22,250 $34
median $53
$3,94818%
typical · median 15%
Mitchell J Paeper
Heather Bramer
Patrick K Rickerl
Holly A Brink
Todd Group
James Heyn
Jolynne Mack
Julia Moes
Alfson Insurance
Sherry M Adams
Tracy L Hostler
Gregg Robson
Luke Smith
Keith A Olson
Douglas Haslip
Michael L Manternach
Travis Ronke
AWS
Jaime Ragins
Cassidy A Goldstine
David Aesoph
Michelle Albea
Brad Lufkin
Melissa J Beck
Herman C Petersen
Nefzeger Enterprises
Andrea L Sweeter
Cory D Nelson
Ashley D Warner
Theodore Honke
Ronald L Hovick
Heidi Alfson
Lisa K Uhlir
Michael J Tomlinson
Shawn D Benser
Angela Sycks
Joshua D Terrell
Melody Thompson
Deborah J Langenfeld Hoops
Abby J Breitling
Jeffrey J Young
Jody L Kludt
Renae Knopf
Jason Garcia
Jarvis Anthony Thomas
Chris A Gustafson
Michael D Evans JR
Eric Palmer
C SUE McKenzie
Tyonia Eggers
Mary L Savold
Sidney Layne Lahr
Sara Kneip
Jeremy L Tomlinson
Kenneth W Steele
Brady L Weisenberger
Naomi C McLaughlin
Tina M Keck
Michael Bolger
Remley Benefits
Mitchell J McCall
Renaldus N Wentz
Austin J Peterson
Performance Plus
Scott R Fritcher
William Clay Arnold
Matthew D Butler
Lance Thorson
Stacey Schrock
Jacquelyn Kimbrough
William M Barnett
Kara M Carmody
James L Layes
Richard R Kimbrough
Heather D Swanson
Bernard J Brazeau
STD SymetraJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
77$21,006 $23
median $53
$6533.1%
below typical · median 15%
Cottingham & Butler

Brokers and agents paid

FirmTypeLocationContractsCommissions + fees
Cottingham & Butler
Fees for: Group Volume Bonus
Insurance agent or brokerDubuque, IA2$6,617
Mitchell J PaeperInsurance agent or brokerCedar Falls, IA1$958
Heather BramerAgent or broker (non-insurance)Watertown, SD1$834
Patrick K RickerlInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$301
Holly A BrinkInsurance agent or brokerNew Hartford, IA1$205
Todd GroupInsurance agent or brokerCedar Falls, IA1$199
James HeynInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$148
Jolynne MackInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$147
Julia MoesInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$90
Alfson InsuranceInsurance agent or brokerHartford, SD1$76
Sherry M AdamsInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$75
Tracy L HostlerInsurance agent or brokerBrookings, SD1$68
Gregg RobsonInsurance agent or brokerMadison, SD1$66
Luke SmithInsurance agent or brokerLake Preston, SD1$64
Keith A OlsonInsurance agent or brokerWest Fargo, ND1$60
Douglas HaslipInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$52
Michael L ManternachInsurance agent or brokerManchester, IA1$43
Travis RonkeInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$40
AWSInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$38
Jaime RaginsInsurance agent or brokerLE Claire, IA1$37
Cassidy A GoldstineInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$35
David AesophInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$30
Michelle AlbeaInsurance agent or brokerBellevue, NE1$30
Brad LufkinInsurance agent or brokerJohnston, IA1$24
Melissa J BeckInsurance agent or brokerHartford, SD1$21
Herman C PetersenInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$16
Nefzeger EnterprisesInsurance agent or brokerLake Norden, SD1$16
Andrea L SweeterInsurance agent or brokerLennox, SD1$16
Cory D NelsonInsurance agent or brokerNorth Liberty, IA1$15
Ashley D WarnerInsurance agent or brokerDE Smet, SD1$15
Theodore HonkeInsurance agent or brokerLake Andes, SD1$15
Ronald L HovickInsurance agent or brokerCape Coral, FL1$14
Heidi AlfsonInsurance agent or brokerHartford, SD1$14
Lisa K UhlirInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$12
Michael J TomlinsonInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$12
Shawn D BenserInsurance agent or brokerMapelton, ND1$11
Angela SycksInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$11
Joshua D TerrellInsurance agent or brokerLake Park, FL1$10
Melody ThompsonInsurance agent or brokerBrookings, SD1$10
Deborah J Langenfeld HoopsInsurance agent or brokerHuron, SD1$10
Abby J BreitlingInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$9
Jeffrey J YoungInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$9
Jody L KludtInsurance agent or brokerLesterville, SD1$8
Renae KnopfInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$7
Jason GarciaInsurance agent or brokerWaterloo, IA1$6
Jarvis Anthony ThomasInsurance agent or brokerDubuque, IA1$6
Chris A GustafsonInsurance agent or brokerBrandon, SD1$6
Michael D Evans JRInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$6
Eric PalmerInsurance agent or brokerMitchell, SD1$5
C SUE McKenzieInsurance agent or brokerSun City, AZ1$5
Tyonia EggersInsurance agent or brokerStorm Lake, IA1$5
Mary L SavoldInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$4
Sidney Layne LahrInsurance agent or brokerDyersville, IA1$4
Sara KneipInsurance agent or brokerBrookings, SD1$4
Jeremy L TomlinsonInsurance agent or brokerBoise, ID1$4
Kenneth W SteeleInsurance agent or brokerSioux Falls, SD1$3
Brady L WeisenbergerInsurance agent or brokerFargo, ND1$3
Naomi C McLaughlinInsurance agent or brokerTea, SD1$2
Tina M KeckInsurance agent or brokerDubuque, IA1$2
Michael BolgerInsurance agent or brokerMadison, SD1$2
Remley BenefitsInsurance agent or brokerClinton, IA1$2
Mitchell J McCallInsurance agent or brokerKeokuk, IA1$1
Renaldus N WentzInsurance agent or brokerBillings, MT1$1
Austin J PetersonInsurance agent or brokerUrbandale, IA1$1
Performance PlusInsurance agent or brokerMitchell, SD1$1
Scott R FritcherInsurance agent or brokerUrbandale, IA1$1
William Clay ArnoldInsurance agent or brokerNatchez, MS1$1
Matthew D ButlerInsurance agent or brokerLoudon, TN1$1
Lance ThorsonInsurance agent or brokerWatertown, SD1$1
Stacey SchrockInsurance agent or brokerDES Moines, IA1$0
Jacquelyn KimbroughInsurance agent or brokerCarlisle, IA1$0
William M BarnettInsurance agent or brokerHartford, SD1$0
Kara M CarmodyInsurance agent or brokerSaint Paul, MN1$0
James L LayesInsurance agent or brokerNorth Liberty, IA1$0
Richard R KimbroughInsurance agent or brokerPalm Bay, FL1$0
Heather D SwansonInsurance agent or brokerWaukee, IA1$0
Bernard J BrazeauInsurance agent or brokerIndianola, IA1$0

Plan-year history, 2019–2025

$1.8M 2019 $1.7M 2020 $1.5M 2021 $1.6M 2022 $1.9M 2023 $1.7M 2024 $1.5M 2025 ●
Schedule A premium by plan year · ● broker of record changed. Source: Form 5500.
Plan yearParticipantsPremiumBroker compMedical fundingTop carriersBrokers
2025180$1.5M$11K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Symetra, Aflac Cottingham & Butler, Mitchell J Paeper, Heather Bramer
Broker of record changed (was Freimark and Associates in 2024)
2024188$1.7M$40K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), MetLife, Reliance Standard (Matrix) Freimark and Associates, GIS Benefits, Heather Bramer
2023204$1.9M$39K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), MetLife, Reliance Standard (Matrix) Freimark and Associates, GIS Benefits, Heather Bramer
2022202$1.6M$68K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Equitable Financial Life Insurance, MetLife Cottingham & Butler, Freimark and Associates, GIS Benefits
2021202$1.5M$63K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), MetLife, Equitable Financial Life Insurance Cottingham & Butler, Freimark and Associates, GIS Benefits
2020219$1.7M$73K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Aflac, MetLife Cottingham & Butler, Freimark and Associates, GIS Benefits
2019233$1.8M$69K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Aflac, MetLife Cottingham & Butler, Freimark and Associates, GIS Benefits

Across all of this employer's welfare plans, as filed. Years with missing or partial filings show smaller totals.

Health and welfare plans

Plan #PlanPlan yearParticipantsBenefitsFundingReceivedOriginal
501Building Products, Inc. Cafeteria PlanJan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025180Health, Dental, Vision, Temporary disability, OtherInsuranceOct 15, 2026Filing PDF
502Building Products Inc. Employee Life Insurance PlanJan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025180Life, Temporary disability, Long-term disability, OtherInsuranceOct 15, 2026Filing PDF

Data as filed with the U.S. Department of Labor, through Oct 24, 2026. Something wrong? Report a data issue.