How to read Schedule A of a Form 5500
Schedule A is the part of a Form 5500 that reports each insurance contract behind a benefit plan. It's where the carrier, the premium and what the insurer paid brokers show up. This guide goes through it part by part, with the codes you'll see.
- What Schedule A is
- The carrier and contract
- Broker commissions and fees
- Benefits, premiums and claims
- What it doesn't show
- On Open5500
- Questions
What Schedule A is
A plan attaches one Schedule A for each insurance contract that provides its benefits: one for the medical contract, one for dental, one for life and disability, and so on. A single employer can file a dozen. Open5500 reads them for all 70,145 employers in the current data.
Plans that pay benefits only from the employer's own assets, with no insurance, file no Schedule A for those benefits. A self-funded plan with stop-loss coverage files one for the stop-loss policy.
The carrier and contract
The top of each Schedule A identifies the contract:
- Insurance carrier name, EIN and NAIC code (the insurer's ID with state regulators).
- Contract or identification number.
- Persons covered at the end of the policy year. Depending on the carrier, that can mean employees or employees plus dependents.
- Policy year start and end dates. The start date is usually the renewal date.
Broker commissions and fees
Next comes a list of everyone the insurer paid commissions or fees on that contract during the policy year, with:
- the name and address of the agent, broker or other person,
- the amount of commissions,
- the amount of fees and what they were paid for (for example consulting, finder's fees or bonuses),
- an organization code describing who was paid.
| Code | Organization |
|---|---|
| 1 | Banking, savings and loan association, credit union or other similar financial institution |
| 2 | Trust company |
| 3 | Insurance agent or broker |
| 4 | Agent or broker other than insurance |
| 5 | Third-party administrator |
| 6 | Investment company or mutual fund |
| 7 | Investment manager or adviser |
| 8 | Labor union |
| 9 | Foreign entity |
| 0 | Other |
Most entries are code 3. The same agency can appear several times, once per office or per producer, and sometimes under an individual agent's name.
Benefits, premiums and claims
The welfare benefit part says what the contract covers, with boxes for health, dental, vision, life, temporary and long-term disability, prescription drugs, stop-loss, HMO, PPO, indemnity and other (with a description). Then it reports the money in one of two ways:
- Experience-rated contracts report premiums earned, claims paid and the change in reserves, which lets you see the claims experience behind the premium.
- Non-experience-rated contracts report the total premium paid to the carrier.
Voluntary and supplemental policies (accident, critical illness, hospital indemnity) often tick the health box. Read the description before treating one as a medical plan.
What it doesn't show
- Fees the employer pays a broker directly. Schedule A only covers what insurers paid.
- Self-funded claims and administration. Those aren't insurance contracts. Service providers paid from plan assets appear on Schedule C instead (see finding an employer's TPA).
- Small plans. Most fully insured plans under 100 participants don't file a Form 5500 at all.
On Open5500
Every employer page has a Schedule A table for the latest plan year: lines, carrier, policy year, persons covered, premium, premium per covered person per month next to the median for that line and group size, broker commissions plus fees, the comp rate next to the typical rate, and who was paid. Offices are rolled up to the parent firm, and amounts larger than the premium are marked as likely filing errors. Market-wide figures are in the broker compensation report.
Questions
Who files Schedule A?
Any plan filing a Form 5500 that has benefits provided through an insurance contract attaches a Schedule A for each contract.
Is the premium on Schedule A annual?
It covers the contract's policy year as reported, which usually lines up with a full year but can be shorter for a new or ending contract.
Why does the same broker appear more than once?
Insurers report each payee separately, so an agency can show up once per office, per producer or per type of payment. Open5500 combines them under the firm.
Nothing here is legal, tax or insurance advice; see the terms.