Utica Mutual Insurance Company
180 Genesee Street, New Hartford, NY 13413. EIN 15-0476880. Self-fundedPlan year 2025
Finance & insurance (NAICS 524290)
Utica Mutual Insurance Company (New Hartford, NY, 1,345 participants) has a self-funded health plan. Its brokers of record are WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group and Watson Wyatt and, paid 8.2% of reported premium (median for this size: 1.0%). Coverage renews in January.
- Participants
- 1,345
- Funding
- Self-funded
- Renews
- January
- Premium
- $2,435,811
- Comp rate
- 8.2%
- Brokers of record
- WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
Lawley Benefits Group
Watson Wyatt and - Carriers by line
- Plan year
- 2025
- Source
- Form 5500, filed 2026
Schedule A contracts, plan year 2025
| Lines | Carrier | Policy year | Covered | Premium | Per covered / mo | Broker comp | Comp rate | Paid to |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Life | Lincoln Financial | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
1,294 | $720,441 | $46 median $37 |
$52,313 | 7.3% typical · median 9.3% |
Lawley Benefits Group |
| Medical | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans) | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
80 | $689,406 | $718 median $573 |
$41,868 | 6.1% above typical · median 1.0% |
WTW (Willis Towers Watson) |
| LTD | Lincoln Financial | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
707 | $490,336 | $58 median $41 |
$38,775 | 7.9% typical · median 9.7% |
Lawley Benefits Group |
| Hospital Indemnity, Vision Voluntary Hospital Indemnity |
Guardian | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
1,029 | $250,481 | $20 median $12 |
$37,324 | 15% above typical · median 2.6% |
WTW (Willis Towers Watson) |
| Other | MetLife | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
650 | $129,601 | $17 median $30 |
$12,380 | 9.6% typical · median 8.0% |
WTW (Willis Towers Watson) |
| Other | MetLife | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
1,016 | $58,363 | $5 median $30 |
$8,033 | 14% typical · median 8.0% |
WTW (Willis Towers Watson) |
| Legal Legal |
Metropolitan General Insurance | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
275 | $48,543 | $15 median $17 |
$5,361 | 11% typical · median 11% |
WTW (Willis Towers Watson) Watson Wyatt and |
| Life | Lincoln Financial | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
69 | $38,416 | $46 median $37 |
$2,790 | 7.3% typical · median 9.3% |
Lawley Benefits Group |
| Medical Health Reimbursement Account |
VIA Benefits | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
186 | $9,224 | $4 median $573 |
$0 | 0.0% | None listed |
| Dental, AD&D Accidental Death & Dismemberment |
Zurich American Insurance | Jan 1, 2025 to Dec 31, 2025 |
1,345 | $1,000 | $0 median $38 |
$0 | 0.0% | None listed |
| Total | $2,435,811 | $198,844 | 8.2% |
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. Commissions and fees as reported. Per covered / mo = premium ÷ covered lives ÷ 12, with the median for the same line and group size.
Premium by plan year
Brokers
| Broker | Since | Broker comp |
|---|---|---|
| WTW (Willis Towers Watson) Insurance agent or broker · New York, NY · fees for Special Programs; Bonus | 2019 | $104,900 |
| Lawley Benefits Group Insurance agent or broker · Buffalo, NY · fees for Supplemental Compensation | 2019 | $93,878 |
| Watson Wyatt and Insurance agent or broker · Arlington, VA · fees for Supplemental Compensation | 2024 | $654 |
Other service providers
| Provider | Service | Fees |
|---|
Schedule C: providers paid $5,000 or more by the plan, mostly on large and self-funded plans. Roles come from the filing's service codes.
Plan-year history, 2019–2025
| Plan year | Participants | Premium | Broker comp | Medical funding | Top carriers | Brokers |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 1,345 | $2.4M | $199K | Self-funded | Lincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian | WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Watson Wyatt and |
| 2024 | 1,401 | $2.6M | $166K | Self-funded | Lincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian | WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Watson Wyatt and |
| 2023 | 1,428 | $2.1M | $181K | Self-funded | Lincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian | Lawley Benefits Group, WTW (Willis Towers Watson) |
| 2022 | 1,372 | $2.1M | $161K | Self-funded | Lincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian | WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits |
| 2021 | 1,325 | $15.1M | $374K | Fully insured | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Lincoln Financial, Guardian | WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits |
| 2020 | 1,309 | $13.5M | $355K | Fully insured | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Lincoln Financial, MetLife | WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits |
| 2019 | 1,297 | $12.9M | $315K | Fully insured | Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Lincoln Financial, Guardian | WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits |
Across all of this employer's welfare plans, as filed. Years with missing or partial filings show smaller totals.
Plans
| Plan | Type | Funding | Participants | Filing |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Benefits Plan (plan 503) Plan year Jan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025 · received Aug 10, 2026 | Health, Life, Dental, Vision, Temporary disability, Prepaid legal, Long-term disability, Severance, Death benefits, Other | Insurance + General assets | 1,345 | Filing PDF |
| Utica Mutual Insurance Company Retiree Health Plan (plan 525) Plan year Jan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025 · received Aug 14, 2026 | Health, Life, Other | Insurance + General assets | 298 | Filing PDF |
Schedule A reports insurance contracts, not enrollment by plan, and self-funded claims don't appear on it. Plans under 100 participants often don't file. Data as filed with the U.S. Department of Labor through Oct 24, 2026. Something wrong? Report a data issue.