Utica Mutual Insurance Company

180 Genesee Street, New Hartford, NY 13413. EIN 15-0476880. Self-fundedPlan year 2025

Finance & insurance (NAICS 524290)

View the original filing

Utica Mutual Insurance Company (New Hartford, NY, 1,345 participants) has a self-funded health plan. Its brokers of record are WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group and Watson Wyatt and, paid 8.2% of reported premium (median for this size: 1.0%). Coverage renews in January.

Participants
1,345
Funding
Self-funded
Renews
January
Premium
$2,435,811
Comp rate
8.2%
Brokers of record
WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
Lawley Benefits Group
Watson Wyatt and
Carriers by line
Plan year
2025

Schedule A contracts, plan year 2025

LinesCarrierPolicy yearCoveredPremiumPer covered / moBroker compComp ratePaid to
Life Lincoln FinancialJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
1,294$720,441 $46
median $37
$52,3137.3%
typical · median 9.3%
Lawley Benefits Group
Medical Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans)Jan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
80$689,406 $718
median $573
$41,8686.1%
above typical · median 1.0%
WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
LTD Lincoln FinancialJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
707$490,336 $58
median $41
$38,7757.9%
typical · median 9.7%
Lawley Benefits Group
Hospital Indemnity, Vision
Voluntary Hospital Indemnity
GuardianJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
1,029$250,481 $20
median $12
$37,32415%
above typical · median 2.6%
WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
Other MetLifeJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
650$129,601 $17
median $30
$12,3809.6%
typical · median 8.0%
WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
Other MetLifeJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
1,016$58,363 $5
median $30
$8,03314%
typical · median 8.0%
WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
Legal
Legal
Metropolitan General InsuranceJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
275$48,543 $15
median $17
$5,36111%
typical · median 11%
WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
Watson Wyatt and
Life Lincoln FinancialJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
69$38,416 $46
median $37
$2,7907.3%
typical · median 9.3%
Lawley Benefits Group
Medical
Health Reimbursement Account
VIA BenefitsJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
186$9,224 $4
median $573
$00.0% None listed
Dental, AD&D
Accidental Death & Dismemberment
Zurich American InsuranceJan 1, 2025
to Dec 31, 2025
1,345$1,000 $0
median $38
$00.0% None listed
Total$2,435,811$198,8448.2%

Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. Commissions and fees as reported. Per covered / mo = premium ÷ covered lives ÷ 12, with the median for the same line and group size.

Premium by plan year

$12.9M 2019 $13.5M 2020 $15.1M 2021 $2.1M 2022 $2.1M 2023 $2.6M 2024 $2.4M 2025
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A, plan years 2019 to 2025.

Brokers

BrokerSinceBroker comp
WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
Insurance agent or broker · New York, NY · fees for Special Programs; Bonus
2019$104,900
Lawley Benefits Group
Insurance agent or broker · Buffalo, NY · fees for Supplemental Compensation
2019$93,878
Watson Wyatt and
Insurance agent or broker · Arlington, VA · fees for Supplemental Compensation
2024$654

Plan-year history, 2019–2025

Plan yearParticipantsPremiumBroker compMedical fundingTop carriersBrokers
20251,345$2.4M$199K Self-fundedLincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Watson Wyatt and
20241,401$2.6M$166K Self-fundedLincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Watson Wyatt and
20231,428$2.1M$181K Self-fundedLincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian Lawley Benefits Group, WTW (Willis Towers Watson)
20221,372$2.1M$161K Self-fundedLincoln Financial, Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Guardian WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits
20211,325$15.1M$374K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Lincoln Financial, Guardian WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits
20201,309$13.5M$355K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Lincoln Financial, MetLife WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits
20191,297$12.9M$315K Fully insuredBlue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Lincoln Financial, Guardian WTW (Willis Towers Watson), Lawley Benefits Group, Liazon Benefits

Across all of this employer's welfare plans, as filed. Years with missing or partial filings show smaller totals.

Plans

PlanTypeFundingParticipantsFiling
Utica Mutual Insurance Company Employee Benefits Plan (plan 503)
Plan year Jan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025 · received Aug 10, 2026
Health, Life, Dental, Vision, Temporary disability, Prepaid legal, Long-term disability, Severance, Death benefits, OtherInsurance + General assets1,345Filing PDF
Utica Mutual Insurance Company Retiree Health Plan (plan 525)
Plan year Jan 1, 2025 – Dec 31, 2025 · received Aug 14, 2026
Health, Life, OtherInsurance + General assets298Filing PDF

Schedule A reports insurance contracts, not enrollment by plan, and self-funded claims don't appear on it. Plans under 100 participants often don't file. Data as filed with the U.S. Department of Labor through Oct 24, 2026. Something wrong? Report a data issue.