Brewster Cheese Company

800 Wabash AVE. South, Brewster, OH 44613. EIN 34-0947090. Self-funded (stop-loss)Plan year 2024

Manufacturing (NAICS 311500)

View the original filing

Brewster Cheese Company (Brewster, OH, 375 participants) has a self-funded health plan with stop-loss from Aultcare Insurance. Its brokers of record are Schauer Group, Huntington Insurance and Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio, paid 4.2% of reported premium (median for this size: 3.6%). Coverage renews in July.

Participants
375
Funding
Self-funded (stop-loss)
Renews
July
Premium
$1,404,264
Comp rate
4.2%
Brokers of record
Schauer Group
Huntington Insurance
Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
Carriers by line
Plan year
2024

Schedule A contracts, plan year 2024

LinesCarrierPolicy yearCoveredPremiumPer covered / moBroker compComp ratePaid to
Stop-Loss, Dental, Medical Aultcare InsuranceJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
334$1,034,308 $258
median $169
$30,9963.0%
typical · median 0.0%
Schauer Group
LTD, Life The StandardJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
375$272,738
experience-rated
$61
median $39
$17,4766.4%
below typical · median 15%
Huntington Insurance
LTD, STD, Life American Heritage Life InsuranceJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
99$44,249 $37
median $39
$4,79111%
typical · median 15%
Huntington Insurance
Erika M Perrin
Katie D Duer
Eisel Solutions
Thomas W Boston
Covey RUN Insurance
LTD, STD, Life American Heritage Life InsuranceJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
85$25,179 $25
median $39
$2,2899.1%
below typical · median 15%
Huntington Insurance
Eisel Solutions
Thomas W Boston
LTD, STD, Life American Heritage Life InsuranceJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
41$14,556 $30
median $39
$1,98214%
typical · median 15%
Huntington Insurance
VAL Young
Eisel Solutions
Thomas W Boston
LTD, STD, Life Unum / ColonialJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
6$5,821 $81
median $39
$2804.8%
below typical · median 15%
Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
Howard B Meszaros
JP Griffeth Enterprises
Virginia Ayles Kezele
William Kezele
LTD, STD, Life Unum / ColonialJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
15$5,323 $30
median $39
$1773.3%
below typical · median 15%
Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
Howard B Meszaros
Dennis N Shay
Other American Heritage Life InsuranceJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
14$1,897 $11
median $31
$28415%
typical · median 13%
Huntington Insurance
LTD, STD, Life Unum / ColonialJul 1, 2024
to Jun 30, 2025
1$193 $16
median $39
$52.6%
below typical · median 15%
Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
Total$1,404,264$58,2804.2%

Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. Commissions and fees as reported. Per covered / mo = premium ÷ covered lives ÷ 12, with the median for the same line and group size.

Premium by plan year

$1.1M 2019 $1.1M 2020 $1.3M 2021 $1.4M 2022 $1.5M 2023 $1.4M 2024
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A, plan years 2019 to 2024.

Brokers

BrokerSinceBroker comp
Schauer Group
Insurance agent or broker · Canton, OH
2021$30,996
Huntington Insurance
Insurance agent or broker · Columbus, OH · fees for Contingent Comp
2019$26,521
Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
Insurance agent or broker · Iselin, NJ
2019$405
Erika M Perrin
Insurance agent or broker · Hartville, OH
2019$92
Eisel Solutions
Insurance agent or broker · Wooster, OH
2023$84
Katie D Duer
Insurance agent or broker · Wadsworth, OH
—$75
Howard B Meszaros
Insurance agent or broker · Plain City, OH
—$36
Thomas W Boston
Insurance agent or broker · Hartville, OH
—$34
VAL Young
Insurance agent or broker · Boise, ID
—$15
Dennis N Shay
Insurance agent or broker · Westerville, OH
—$10
JP Griffeth Enterprises
Insurance agent or broker · Boise, ID
—$6
Virginia Ayles Kezele
Insurance agent or broker · Goodyear, AZ
—$3
William Kezele
Insurance agent or broker · Idaho Falls, ID
—$2
Covey RUN Insurance
Insurance agent or broker · Amherst, OH
—$1

Plan-year history, 2019–2024

Plan yearParticipantsPremiumBroker compMedical fundingTop carriersBrokers
2024375$1.4M$58K Self-funded (stop-loss)Aultcare Insurance, The Standard, American Heritage Life Insurance Schauer Group, Huntington Insurance, Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
2023377$1.5M$51K Self-funded (stop-loss)Aultcare Insurance, The Standard, Principal Schauer Group, Huntington Insurance, Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
2022323$1.4M$95K Self-funded (stop-loss)Aultcare Insurance, The Standard, Principal Schauer Group, Huntington Insurance, Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
2021353$1.3M$42K Self-funded (stop-loss)Anthem / Elevance, Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance Huntington Insurance, Schauer Group, Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio
2020355$1.1M$37K Self-funded (stop-loss)Anthem / Elevance, Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance Huntington Insurance, Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio, Michael T Eisel
2019386$1.1M$39K Self-funded (stop-loss)Anthem / Elevance, Principal, American Heritage Life Insurance Huntington Insurance, Integrated Employee Benefit Solutio, Michael T Eisel

Across all of this employer's welfare plans, as filed. Years with missing or partial filings show smaller totals.

Plans

PlanTypeFundingParticipantsFiling
Brewster Dairy Employee Health Insurance Plan (plan 501)
Plan year Jul 1, 2024 – Jun 30, 2025 · received Jan 5, 2026
Health, Life, Dental, Vision, Long-term disability, Other, Temporary disabilityInsurance + General assets375Filing PDF

What this page can't tell you: Schedule A reports insurance contracts, not enrollment by plan, and self-funded claims don't appear on it. Plans under 100 participants often don't file. Data as filed with the U.S. Department of Labor through Oct 24, 2026. Something wrong? Report a data issue.