Independent Health Benefits

Group insurance carrier. Employers from Form 5500 filings, plan years to 2025.

Independent Health Benefits insures 57 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, mostly Medical, Rx, Vision, Stop-Loss, with $117M of reported premium. Median broker compensation on its contracts is 1.8% of premium.

Employers
57
Premium on Schedule A
$117,182,420
Covered lives
10,723
Median comp rate
1.8% across 59 contracts
Top lines
Medical, Rx, Vision, Stop-Loss
Top brokers
Lawley, Gallagher, Mercer, Independent Health
Fully insured market (CMS 2024)
$355M small group, $268M large group
Source
Form 5500, Schedule A; CMS Medical Loss Ratio reports

Largest employers

EmployerStateParticipantsFundingRenewsPremium
Independent Health Association, Inc.NY1,492Fully insuredJan$29.3M
People Inc.NY4,569Fully insuredJan$17.0M
Aspire of Western New York, Inc.NY505Fully insuredJan$9.7M
Mattel, Inc.CA3,527Fully insuredJan$19.2M
Child and Family Services of Erie CountyNY613Fully insuredJan$4.4M
Nysarc, Inc. Erie County ChapterNY522Fully insuredJan$3.6M
Hospice & Palliative Care Buffalo, Inc.NY346Fully insuredJan$3.1M
Canisius UniversityNY302Fully insuredJul$3.3M
Hamister Group, LLCNY900Fully insuredSep$3.4M
New Directions Youth & Family Services, Inc.NY185Fully insuredJan$2.5M
Arbor Realty SR, Inc.NY627Fully insuredSep$10.3M
Jericho Road Ministries, IncNY322Fully insuredMar$2.6M

Show all 57 employers

Lines of coverage

LineEmployersShare
Medical57100%
Rx3663%
Vision35.3%
Stop-Loss11.8%

Employers with at least one Independent Health Benefits contract for each line.

Employers by plan year

42 2019 47 2020 47 2021 65 2022 65 2023 61 2024 43 2025
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. 2025 is still filling in: many plans haven't filed yet.

Where it's placed

StateEmployersShare
New York4375%
California35.3%
Ohio23.5%
Pennsylvania23.5%
Illinois23.5%
Georgia11.8%
Utah11.8%
Michigan11.8%
Florida11.8%
Washington11.8%

Brokers placing it

BrokerEmployersShare
Lawley712%
Gallagher47.0%
Mercer11.8%
Independent Health11.8%
Lockton11.8%
Unknown11.8%
EPIC (Edgewood Partners)11.8%
Tompkins Insurance Agencies11.8%
Brown & Brown11.8%
Aebly and Associates Insurance Services11.8%

Firms paid on this carrier's contracts; individual agents aren't shown.

Medical funding of its employers

FundingEmployersShare
Fully insured4274%
Self-funded916%
Mixed35.3%
Self-funded (stop-loss)23.5%
Unknown11.8%

Fully insured group health market share, MLR and rebates by state (2024)

Nationally: $355M small-group premium (53,816 covered lives) and $268M large-group (33,646 lives).

StateSmall group shareLarge group share
NY4.7%
#5 · $355M · MLR 101%
1.4%
#10 · $268M · MLR 95%

Fully insured comprehensive medical only, from insurers' 2024 Medical Loss Ratio reports to CMS (published about two years later). MLR is the official 3-year, credibility-adjusted share of premium spent on claims and quality improvement (2022–2024); the federal minimum is 80% for small group and 85% for large group, and insurers below it owe rebates to employers and members. A carrier's blended MLR can be above the minimum while one of its companies still owes a rebate. Self-funded and level-funded plans aren't included. "Small group" is generally 1–50 employees (1–100 in CA, CO, NY and VT). Some California HMOs that report to the state instead may be missing. Source: CMS MLR public use file.

What this page can't tell you: Schedule A shows insured contracts, so administrative-services-only (ASO) business for self-funded plans mostly isn't here, and plans under 100 participants often don't file. Something wrong? Report a data issue.