Shepherd

Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings

Shepherd is the broker of record for 53 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 27,490 participants, most in IN, KY, OH. Commissions and fees average 1.7% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 0 and lost 2 broker-of-record relationships.

Employers
53
Participants
27,490
Premium placed
$139M
Commissions + fees
$2.3M
Comp rate
1.7%

See all brokers in Open5500 →

Where the book is

Carriers on this book

Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.

Group size and funding

Recent wins (0)

None in the latest two plan years.

Recent losses (2)

EmployerNew brokerPlan year
Schilling Brothers Lumber & Hardware Inc.
Saint John, IN
Centro Benefits2025
Epika Fleet Services, Inc.
Nashville, TN
Shepard Insurance2025

A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

Largest employers

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
Kentucky Construction Industry Trust
Lexington, KY
6,612Fully insuredApr$61.2M
Industrial Manufacturing and Professional Commercial Trust
Lexington, KY
3,831Fully insuredJan$24.1M
First Merchants Corporation
Muncie, IN
1,964Self-fundedJan$2.2M
Barnes & Thornburg LLP
Indianapolis, IN
1,290Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$5.7M
Martin & Bayley, Inc.
Carmi, IL
940Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$1.6M
TC Heartland LLC
Carmel, IN
933Fully insuredJan$7.8M
Impact Energy Trust
Lexington, KY
853Fully insuredJul$11.2M
Liberty Federal Credit Union
Evansville, IN
817No medical reportedJan$683K
Ice Miller LLP
Indianapolis, IN
636Self-fundedJan$1.3M
Rose-hulman Institute of Technology
Terre Haute, IN
621Self-fundedJan$1.1M
Eckart, LLC
Corydon, IN
536Self-fundedOct$405K
Shepherd Insurance, LLC
Carmel, IN
532Self-fundedMay$581K
Shepherd Insurance
Louisville, KY
471Fully insuredJan$6.8M
Selectransportation Resources, L.L.C.
Houston, TX
388Self-funded (stop-loss)Oct$2.3M
Howard Companies LLC
Indianapolis, IN
359Self-fundedJan$515K
The Wells Group, LLC
West Liberty, KY
327Self-funded (stop-loss)Jul$585K
Unity Healthcare, LLC
Lafayette, IN
288Self-fundedJan$341K
Ireland Home Based Services, LLC
Evansville, IN
286Self-fundedFeb$250K
Vandor Corporation
Richmond, IN
271Self-fundedJan$204K
Ivan Ware & Son, Inc.
Louisville, KY
269Self-fundedJan$330K
Forte Sports Medicine and Orthopedics DBA Methodist Sports Medicine CE
Carmel, IN
255Self-funded (stop-loss)Oct$763K
Walor North America
Columbus, OH
250Fully insuredJan$2.6M
AHF Industries, Inc.
French Lick, IN
243Fully insuredJul$518K
John Jones Salem Dealerships, Inc.
Salem, IN
229Fully insuredJan$1.8M
Cornerstone Builders of Swfl, Inc.
Fort Meyers, FL
215Fully insuredJul$1.1M
Fleet Mobile Service, Inc.
Nashville, TN
209Fully insuredOct$1.9M
Commercial Maintenance Services, LLC
Richmond, IN
208Self-fundedJan$59K
Vomac Truck Sales & Service, Inc.
Evansville, IN
203UnknownFeb$191K
J.C. Hart Company, Inc.
Carmel, IN
191Fully insuredJan$1.9M
Retirement Living, Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
189Self-fundedJan$225K
Bionic Prosthetics and Orthotics and Orthotics Group LLC
Merrillville, IN
186Fully insuredApr$879K
Sarkes Tarzian, Inc
Bloomington, IN
182MixedJan$651K
Merrell Bros., Inc.
Kokomo, IN
176Fully insuredJul$1.7M
Josephson-wallack-munshower Neurology, P.C.
Indianapolis, IN
171No medical reportedJan$99K
Indiana Legal Services, Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
161Fully insuredJan$2.5M
Vernet US Corporation
Columbus, IN
158Fully insuredJan$1.9M
Viwintech Window & Door, Inc.
Paducah, KY
149Self-fundedOct$123K
F.C. Tucker Company, LLC
Indianapolis, IN
148Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$520K
Mervis Motors, Inc.
Richmond, IN
145Self-fundedNov$82K
D-A Lubricant Company, Inc.
Lebanon, IN
140No medical reportedJul$77K
Centers for Pain Control, Inc.
LA Porte, IN
140No medical reportedJun$58K
Jagoe Homes
Owensboro, KY
128Fully insuredJul$1.1M
Dermatology, Inc.
Greenwood, IN
128No medical reportedJan$58K
Decatur Mold Tool & Engineering Inc
North Vernon, IN
124Self-fundedJan$166K
Fred Smith Store Fixtures, Inc.
Depauw, IN
123Fully insuredNov$1.0M
Shepherd Oil Company, LLC
Blackwell, OK
117Fully insuredOct$859K
Options Schools, Inc.
Noblesville, IN
116Fully insuredSep$1.7M
River City Foundations
Louisville, KY
113Fully insuredApr$738K
CSO Architects, Inc.
Indianapolis, IN
105Self-fundedJan$118K
Lower Great Lakes Kenworth, Inc.
South Bend, IN
98Self-fundedJan$14K

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.