Paychex Insurance Agency

Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings

Paychex Insurance Agency is the broker of record for 140 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 194,923 participants, most in NY, CA, FL. Commissions and fees average 2.8% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 3 and lost 11 broker-of-record relationships.

Employers
140
Participants
194,923
Premium placed
$150M
Commissions + fees
$4.2M
Comp rate
2.8%

See all brokers in Open5500 →

Where the book is

Carriers on this book

Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.

Group size and funding

Recent wins (3)

EmployerPrevious brokerPlan year
Metro Mold & Design LLC
Rogers, MN
Marsh McLennan Agency2025
Suburban Capital, LLC
Virginia Beach, VA
Frieden Agency2024
Arrowood Indemnity Commpany
Charlotte, NC
Mercer2024

Recent losses (11)

EmployerNew brokerPlan year
Terran Orbital Corporation
Irvine, CA
OneDigital2025
Norwood Staffing Solutions LLC
Sunset Valley, TX
Experins2025
LA Cava Jacobson & Goodis, P.A.
Tampa, FL
Marsh McLennan Agency2024
Fresh Made Kitchen Restaurant Group, LLC
Wildwood, FL
Baldwin Group2024
Malik Consulting Inc.
Atlanta, GA
USI Insurance Services2024
Feeding South Florida
Pembroke Park, FL
Gallagher2024
MRB Group Engineering, Architecture & Surveying, DPC
Rochester, NY
Consiliarium Group2025
Rockwell Building Systems, LLC
Riverview, FL
Higginbotham2024
Seasons Management LLC
Lake Oswego, OR
Brown & Brown2024
Crosman Corporation
Bloomfield, NY
Risk Strategies2024
Total Operations and Production Services, LLC
Midland, TX
IMA2024

A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

Largest employers

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
The Business Council of New York State, Inc. Insurance Fund
Albany, NY
150,644No medical reportedJan$39.2M
Metz Culinary Management
Dallas, PA
5,265Self-fundedMar$851K
Midwest Health, Inc.
Topeka, KS
3,000Self-fundedJan$1.0M
Stanley Electric Holding of America, Inc.
Battle Creek, MI
2,750Self-fundedJan$1.3M
Elevate PFS Holdings, Inc.
Spring, TX
2,715Self-fundedJan$4.7M
F.F. Thompson Health System, Inc.
Canandaigua, NY
1,618Self-fundedJan$1.2M
Tippmann Group
Fort Wayne, IN
1,353Self-fundedAug$1.8M
Linchris Hotel Corporation
Hanover, MA
1,117Self-fundedJan$489K
Fuentes Restaurant Management
Dallas, TX
970UnknownJan$761K
IMA Group Management Company
RYE Brook, NY
847Fully insuredApr$6.5M
Midland Paper Company
Wheeling, IL
805Fully insuredApr$2.5M
Focus Staff Services, LP
Dallas, TX
801Fully insuredJan$2.9M
Darktrace, Inc
SAN Francisco, CA
746Fully insuredJul$2.0M
Jobot, LLC
Newport Beach, CA
607Fully insuredFeb$8.2M
Pride Rock Capital Management
Palm Beach Gardens, FL
587Fully insuredJan$1.8M
Kaplan Development Group
Jericho, NY
490Fully insuredJan$3.0M
Ridgeline Management Company
Rockwall, TX
468Fully insuredDec$1.8M
Hyundai Autoever America, LLC
Irvine, CA
465Fully insuredNov$1.3M
XPT Group LLC
New Haven, CT
465Fully insuredJan$5.3M
Keystone Pacific Property Management LLC
Irvine, CA
402Fully insuredMay$3.3M
Birdon America Inc
Denver, CO
363Fully insuredJan$920K
Real Capital Partners LP
Winter Garden, FL
350Self-fundedJan$255K
Holbrook Life Management, LLC
Alpharetta, GA
326Fully insuredMay$846K
Tvg-medulla LLC
Oak Brook, IL
324Fully insuredJan$3.5M
Rodgers & Houder Inc.
Oak Brook, IL
313Fully insuredSep$1.9M
Nutraco LLC
Fort Laudedale, FL
311Fully insuredJan$459K
Evoke Health Care Management LLC
Miramar, FL
298Fully insuredMar$1.3M
Electronic Power Design Inc.
Houston, TX
289Fully insuredOct$2.6M
Theoria Medical Pllc
Novi, MI
280Fully insuredJan$2.7M
Concern for Independent Living, Inc
Medford, NY
264Fully insuredJan$2.7M
Freedom Senior Share, LLC
Louisville, KY
263No medical reportedJan$249K
Graceland Management Services, LLC
Bardwell, KY
263Fully insuredDec$1.7M
Ultrafab, Inc.
Farmington, NY
255Fully insuredJan$3.2M
AVA OP LLC
Albertville, MN
249Fully insuredJan$1.7M
Keeler Intermediate Holdings LLC
Latham, NY
247UnknownJan$358K
Plato Academy Schools Corporation
Clearwater, FL
246Fully insuredOct$1.9M
Wyssta Care, Inc.
Stevens Point, WI
240Fully insuredJan$1.6M
Calvary Automation Systems
Webster, NY
239Fully insuredJan$2.4M
Premier Senior Living - Delaware, LLC
Petaluma, CA
232Self-fundedJan$138K
Skin Cancer & Cosmetic Dermatology
Dalton, GA
231Fully insuredJun$694K
Auxilio Inc
Cincinnati, OH
228UnknownJan$164K
Origin BJJ
Farmington, ME
228Fully insuredOct$1.2M
Shore-line Carpet Supplies of Gulf Coast Inc.
Naples, FL
227Fully insuredDec$2.0M
Healthfirst Bluegrass Inc
Lexington, KY
224Fully insuredJan$2.5M
Metcon Inc
Pembroke, NC
223Self-fundedJan$80K
Express Courier International Inc.
Nashville, TN
215Fully insuredJan$2.2M
Cherry Tree Dental LLC
Madison, WI
215Fully insuredJan$1.3M
Olympus Ventures LLC
Minneapolis, MN
209No medical reportedJan$288K
Meridian Management Services
Newport Beach, CA
205Fully insuredMar$577K
Dragonfly Pond Works LLC
Raleigh, NC
203Fully insuredJan$816K

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.