Paychex Insurance Agency
Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings
Paychex Insurance Agency is the broker of record for 140 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 194,923 participants, most in NY, CA, FL. Commissions and fees average 2.8% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 3 and lost 11 broker-of-record relationships.
Employers
140
Participants
194,923
Premium placed
$150M
Commissions + fees
$4.2M
Comp rate
2.8%
Where the book is
Carriers on this book
- Unum / Colonial 29
- Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans) 27
- UnitedHealthcare 19
- Principal 16
- Cigna 13
- Guardian 13
- Sun Life 9
- Anthem / Elevance 8
- Aflac 8
- Kaiser Permanente 7
Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.
Group size and funding
- 0–49 participants 8
- 50–99 participants 8
- 100–249 participants 91
- 250–499 participants 18
- 500–999 participants 7
- 1,000–4,999 participants 6
- 5,000+ participants 2
- Fully insured 92 (66%)
- Self-funded 21 (15%)
- No medical reported 19 (14%)
- Unknown 5 (4%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 3 (2%)
Recent wins (3)
| Employer | Previous broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Metro Mold & Design LLC Rogers, MN | Marsh McLennan Agency | 2025 |
| Suburban Capital, LLC Virginia Beach, VA | Frieden Agency | 2024 |
| Arrowood Indemnity Commpany Charlotte, NC | Mercer | 2024 |
Recent losses (11)
| Employer | New broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Terran Orbital Corporation Irvine, CA | OneDigital | 2025 |
| Norwood Staffing Solutions LLC Sunset Valley, TX | Experins | 2025 |
| LA Cava Jacobson & Goodis, P.A. Tampa, FL | Marsh McLennan Agency | 2024 |
| Fresh Made Kitchen Restaurant Group, LLC Wildwood, FL | Baldwin Group | 2024 |
| Malik Consulting Inc. Atlanta, GA | USI Insurance Services | 2024 |
| Feeding South Florida Pembroke Park, FL | Gallagher | 2024 |
| MRB Group Engineering, Architecture & Surveying, DPC Rochester, NY | Consiliarium Group | 2025 |
| Rockwell Building Systems, LLC Riverview, FL | Higginbotham | 2024 |
| Seasons Management LLC Lake Oswego, OR | Brown & Brown | 2024 |
| Crosman Corporation Bloomfield, NY | Risk Strategies | 2024 |
| Total Operations and Production Services, LLC Midland, TX | IMA | 2024 |
A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| The Business Council of New York State, Inc. Insurance Fund Albany, NY | 150,644 | No medical reported | Jan | $39.2M |
| Metz Culinary Management Dallas, PA | 5,265 | Self-funded | Mar | $851K |
| Midwest Health, Inc. Topeka, KS | 3,000 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.0M |
| Stanley Electric Holding of America, Inc. Battle Creek, MI | 2,750 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.3M |
| Elevate PFS Holdings, Inc. Spring, TX | 2,715 | Self-funded | Jan | $4.7M |
| F.F. Thompson Health System, Inc. Canandaigua, NY | 1,618 | Self-funded | Jan | $1.2M |
| Tippmann Group Fort Wayne, IN | 1,353 | Self-funded | Aug | $1.8M |
| Linchris Hotel Corporation Hanover, MA | 1,117 | Self-funded | Jan | $489K |
| Fuentes Restaurant Management Dallas, TX | 970 | Unknown | Jan | $761K |
| IMA Group Management Company RYE Brook, NY | 847 | Fully insured | Apr | $6.5M |
| Midland Paper Company Wheeling, IL | 805 | Fully insured | Apr | $2.5M |
| Focus Staff Services, LP Dallas, TX | 801 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.9M |
| Darktrace, Inc SAN Francisco, CA | 746 | Fully insured | Jul | $2.0M |
| Jobot, LLC Newport Beach, CA | 607 | Fully insured | Feb | $8.2M |
| Pride Rock Capital Management Palm Beach Gardens, FL | 587 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.8M |
| Kaplan Development Group Jericho, NY | 490 | Fully insured | Jan | $3.0M |
| Ridgeline Management Company Rockwall, TX | 468 | Fully insured | Dec | $1.8M |
| Hyundai Autoever America, LLC Irvine, CA | 465 | Fully insured | Nov | $1.3M |
| XPT Group LLC New Haven, CT | 465 | Fully insured | Jan | $5.3M |
| Keystone Pacific Property Management LLC Irvine, CA | 402 | Fully insured | May | $3.3M |
| Birdon America Inc Denver, CO | 363 | Fully insured | Jan | $920K |
| Real Capital Partners LP Winter Garden, FL | 350 | Self-funded | Jan | $255K |
| Holbrook Life Management, LLC Alpharetta, GA | 326 | Fully insured | May | $846K |
| Tvg-medulla LLC Oak Brook, IL | 324 | Fully insured | Jan | $3.5M |
| Rodgers & Houder Inc. Oak Brook, IL | 313 | Fully insured | Sep | $1.9M |
| Nutraco LLC Fort Laudedale, FL | 311 | Fully insured | Jan | $459K |
| Evoke Health Care Management LLC Miramar, FL | 298 | Fully insured | Mar | $1.3M |
| Electronic Power Design Inc. Houston, TX | 289 | Fully insured | Oct | $2.6M |
| Theoria Medical Pllc Novi, MI | 280 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.7M |
| Concern for Independent Living, Inc Medford, NY | 264 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.7M |
| Freedom Senior Share, LLC Louisville, KY | 263 | No medical reported | Jan | $249K |
| Graceland Management Services, LLC Bardwell, KY | 263 | Fully insured | Dec | $1.7M |
| Ultrafab, Inc. Farmington, NY | 255 | Fully insured | Jan | $3.2M |
| AVA OP LLC Albertville, MN | 249 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.7M |
| Keeler Intermediate Holdings LLC Latham, NY | 247 | Unknown | Jan | $358K |
| Plato Academy Schools Corporation Clearwater, FL | 246 | Fully insured | Oct | $1.9M |
| Wyssta Care, Inc. Stevens Point, WI | 240 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.6M |
| Calvary Automation Systems Webster, NY | 239 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.4M |
| Premier Senior Living - Delaware, LLC Petaluma, CA | 232 | Self-funded | Jan | $138K |
| Skin Cancer & Cosmetic Dermatology Dalton, GA | 231 | Fully insured | Jun | $694K |
| Auxilio Inc Cincinnati, OH | 228 | Unknown | Jan | $164K |
| Origin BJJ Farmington, ME | 228 | Fully insured | Oct | $1.2M |
| Shore-line Carpet Supplies of Gulf Coast Inc. Naples, FL | 227 | Fully insured | Dec | $2.0M |
| Healthfirst Bluegrass Inc Lexington, KY | 224 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.5M |
| Metcon Inc Pembroke, NC | 223 | Self-funded | Jan | $80K |
| Express Courier International Inc. Nashville, TN | 215 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.2M |
| Cherry Tree Dental LLC Madison, WI | 215 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.3M |
| Olympus Ventures LLC Minneapolis, MN | 209 | No medical reported | Jan | $288K |
| Meridian Management Services Newport Beach, CA | 205 | Fully insured | Mar | $577K |
| Dragonfly Pond Works LLC Raleigh, NC | 203 | Fully insured | Jan | $816K |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.