Keystone Insurance and Benefits Group
Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings
Keystone Insurance and Benefits Group is the broker of record for 38 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 11,277 participants, most in IL, IN, KY. Commissions and fees average 4.5% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 1 and lost 3 broker-of-record relationships.
Employers
38
Participants
11,277
Premium placed
$27.1M
Commissions + fees
$1.2M
Comp rate
4.5%
Where the book is
Carriers on this book
- MetLife 13
- Lincoln Financial 8
- Anthem / Elevance 8
- Principal 3
- Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans) 3
- UnitedHealthcare 3
- Unum / Colonial 2
- Health Resources 1
- The Hartford 1
- EyeMed / Fidelity Security Life 1
Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.
Group size and funding
- 0–49 participants 2
- 50–99 participants 1
- 100–249 participants 21
- 250–499 participants 9
- 500–999 participants 3
- 1,000–4,999 participants 2
- Fully insured 19 (50%)
- Self-funded 8 (21%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 6 (16%)
- No medical reported 4 (11%)
- Unknown 1 (3%)
Recent wins (1)
| Employer | Previous broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Shelby Gravel, Inc. D/B/A Shelby Materials Shelbyville, IN | McGowan Benefit Group | 2025 |
Recent losses (3)
| Employer | New broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Elmington Property Management LLC Nashville, TN | Brown & Brown | 2025 |
| Fort Wayne Orthopaedics, LLC Fort Wayne, IN | Nxtgen | 2025 |
| Applied Behavioral Services St Peters, MO | RCP Alera Group | 2025 |
A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SGA Dental Partners Opco, LLC Richmond Hill, GA | 1,468 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $2.7M |
| Keystone Insurers Group, Inc. Northumberland, PA | 1,459 | Fully insured | Jan | $5.3M |
| Frauenshuh Hospitality, LLC Minneapolis, MN | 560 | Fully insured | Jan | $4.4M |
| Crest Foods Co., Inc. Ashton, IL | 556 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $1.1M |
| Shelby Gravel, Inc. D/B/A Shelby Materials Shelbyville, IN | 509 | Self-funded | Apr | $312K |
| Shepherd Insurance Louisville, KY | 471 | Fully insured | Jan | $6.8M |
| Community Schools of Frankfort Frankfort, IN | 406 | Fully insured | Jan | $3.5M |
| Parent Petroleum, Inc. Saint Charles, IL | 405 | Fully insured | Jul | $2.5M |
| Cleary Construction, Inc. Tompkinsville, KY | 368 | Unknown | Jan | $203K |
| Mountain State Auto Auction Inc. Shinnston, WV | 352 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jul | $1.1M |
| Mainscape, Inc. Fishers, IN | 339 | Fully insured | Jan | $763K |
| Global Water Technology, Inc. Calumet City, IL | 330 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.4M |
| Pluri Potent Partnership LLC DBA Omfs Partners Charlotte, NC | 257 | Self-funded | Jan | $169K |
| Kawasaki Tennessee, Inc. Morristown, TN | 255 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.8M |
| Quincy Farm Supply Co. Quincy, IL | 237 | Self-funded | Jan | $155K |
| Upstaging, Inc. Sycamore, IL | 236 | Fully insured | Jul | $4.2M |
| Prairie Quest, Inc. Fort Wayne, IN | 227 | No medical reported | Aug | $79K |
| Marcho Farms, Inc. Souderton, PA | 222 | Self-funded | Jul | $39K |
| Field & Main Bank Henderson, KY | 201 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.4M |
| Kratzenberg & Associates Inc. Irwin, PA | 192 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.7M |
| Rollie Williams Paint Spot Elkhart, IN | 172 | Fully insured | Oct | — |
| Spectra Tech, Inc. Oak Ridge, TN | 171 | No medical reported | Jan | $238K |
| Flight Check Commercial Aviation Services, LLC Bensenville, IL | 165 | Fully insured | Dec | $2.2M |
| Good Samaritan Home Quincy, IL | 162 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.9M |
| Niece Trucking, Inc. DES Moines, IA | 161 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Apr | $431K |
| Gates Automotive Corporation South Bend, IN | 155 | Self-funded | Oct | $178K |
| The Center for Individual and Family Services Mansfield, OH | 150 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.3M |
| Nine Line Apparel Savannah, GA | 148 | No medical reported | Jan | $52K |
| Probity, Inc. Herndon, VA | 142 | Self-funded | May | $553K |
| Boltaron Inc Newcomerstown, OH | 127 | Self-funded | Jan | $205K |
| Coolsoft LLC Louisville, KY | 116 | Fully insured | Jan | $753K |
| Cole Lumber Company, Inc. Scottsville, KY | 115 | Fully insured | Mar | $989K |
| Citizens Savings Bank Clarks Summit, PA | 109 | No medical reported | Jan | $37K |
| HNB National Bank Hannibal, MO | 107 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $739K |
| Reschcor Inc Bristol, IN | 105 | Self-funded | Oct | $161K |
| TP Orthodontics, Inc. Laporte, IN | 63 | Fully insured | Jan | $973K |
| Sunset Home Quincy, IL | 39 | Fully insured | Jan | $626K |
| Mancan, Inc Massillon, OH | 20 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | May | $31K |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.