Keystone Insurance and Benefits Group

Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings

Keystone Insurance and Benefits Group is the broker of record for 38 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 11,277 participants, most in IL, IN, KY. Commissions and fees average 4.5% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 1 and lost 3 broker-of-record relationships.

Employers
38
Participants
11,277
Premium placed
$27.1M
Commissions + fees
$1.2M
Comp rate
4.5%

See all brokers in Open5500 →

Where the book is

Carriers on this book

Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.

Group size and funding

Recent wins (1)

EmployerPrevious brokerPlan year
Shelby Gravel, Inc. D/B/A Shelby Materials
Shelbyville, IN
McGowan Benefit Group2025

Recent losses (3)

EmployerNew brokerPlan year
Elmington Property Management LLC
Nashville, TN
Brown & Brown2025
Fort Wayne Orthopaedics, LLC
Fort Wayne, IN
Nxtgen2025
Applied Behavioral Services
St Peters, MO
RCP Alera Group2025

A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

Largest employers

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
SGA Dental Partners Opco, LLC
Richmond Hill, GA
1,468Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$2.7M
Keystone Insurers Group, Inc.
Northumberland, PA
1,459Fully insuredJan$5.3M
Frauenshuh Hospitality, LLC
Minneapolis, MN
560Fully insuredJan$4.4M
Crest Foods Co., Inc.
Ashton, IL
556Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$1.1M
Shelby Gravel, Inc. D/B/A Shelby Materials
Shelbyville, IN
509Self-fundedApr$312K
Shepherd Insurance
Louisville, KY
471Fully insuredJan$6.8M
Community Schools of Frankfort
Frankfort, IN
406Fully insuredJan$3.5M
Parent Petroleum, Inc.
Saint Charles, IL
405Fully insuredJul$2.5M
Cleary Construction, Inc.
Tompkinsville, KY
368UnknownJan$203K
Mountain State Auto Auction Inc.
Shinnston, WV
352Self-funded (stop-loss)Jul$1.1M
Mainscape, Inc.
Fishers, IN
339Fully insuredJan$763K
Global Water Technology, Inc.
Calumet City, IL
330Fully insuredJan$1.4M
Pluri Potent Partnership LLC DBA Omfs Partners
Charlotte, NC
257Self-fundedJan$169K
Kawasaki Tennessee, Inc.
Morristown, TN
255Fully insuredJan$2.8M
Quincy Farm Supply Co.
Quincy, IL
237Self-fundedJan$155K
Upstaging, Inc.
Sycamore, IL
236Fully insuredJul$4.2M
Prairie Quest, Inc.
Fort Wayne, IN
227No medical reportedAug$79K
Marcho Farms, Inc.
Souderton, PA
222Self-fundedJul$39K
Field & Main Bank
Henderson, KY
201Fully insuredJan$1.4M
Kratzenberg & Associates Inc.
Irwin, PA
192Fully insuredJan$1.7M
Rollie Williams Paint Spot
Elkhart, IN
172Fully insuredOct—
Spectra Tech, Inc.
Oak Ridge, TN
171No medical reportedJan$238K
Flight Check Commercial Aviation Services, LLC
Bensenville, IL
165Fully insuredDec$2.2M
Good Samaritan Home
Quincy, IL
162Fully insuredJan$2.9M
Niece Trucking, Inc.
DES Moines, IA
161Self-funded (stop-loss)Apr$431K
Gates Automotive Corporation
South Bend, IN
155Self-fundedOct$178K
The Center for Individual and Family Services
Mansfield, OH
150Fully insuredJan$1.3M
Nine Line Apparel
Savannah, GA
148No medical reportedJan$52K
Probity, Inc.
Herndon, VA
142Self-fundedMay$553K
Boltaron Inc
Newcomerstown, OH
127Self-fundedJan$205K
Coolsoft LLC
Louisville, KY
116Fully insuredJan$753K
Cole Lumber Company, Inc.
Scottsville, KY
115Fully insuredMar$989K
Citizens Savings Bank
Clarks Summit, PA
109No medical reportedJan$37K
HNB National Bank
Hannibal, MO
107Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$739K
Reschcor Inc
Bristol, IN
105Self-fundedOct$161K
TP Orthodontics, Inc.
Laporte, IN
63Fully insuredJan$973K
Sunset Home
Quincy, IL
39Fully insuredJan$626K
Mancan, Inc
Massillon, OH
20Self-funded (stop-loss)May$31K

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.