Cotter Consulting and Benefits

Employee benefits broker. Book of business from Form 5500 filings, plan years to 2025.

Cotter Consulting and Benefits is the broker of record for 5 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 1,474 participants, most in WA, CA. Commissions and fees average 0.5% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on.

Employers
5
Participants
1,474
Premium placed
$314,978
Commissions and fees
$1,701
Comp rate
0.5%
Broker changes
0 gained, 0 lost
Top carriers
Aflac
Source
Form 5500, Schedule A

Largest employers

EmployerStateParticipantsFundingRenewsPremiumComp rateCarriers
Olive CrestCA691Fully insuredApr$6.2M0.4%Aflac
South West Plumbing & WaterheatersWA260Fully insuredNov$2.0M0.4%Aflac
Kitsap BankWA250Fully insuredJan$318K1.0%Aflac
Homecare Products, Inc.WA152Fully insuredJan$1.9M0.1%Aflac
Tube Art Displays IncWA121Fully insuredJan$1.2M2.0%Aflac

Show all 5 employers

Carriers placed with

CarrierPremiumShare
Aflac$314,978100%

Premium on the Schedule A contracts this firm is paid on.

Employers by plan year

3 2019 6 2020 4 2021 5 2022 3 2023 4 2024 3 2025
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. 2025 is still filling in: many plans haven't filed yet.

Where the book is

StateEmployersParticipantsPremium
Washington4783$119,675
California1691$195,303
Total51,474$314,978

Wins and losses, latest two plan years

Gained: 0 employers

None in the latest two plan years.

Lost: 0 employers

None in the latest two plan years.

Net change: +0 employers. A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all; acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

What this page can't tell you: brokers appear only where they're listed on Schedule A, so plans that pay a consultant directly (Schedule C) aren't in this book. Plans under 100 participants often don't file. Something wrong? Report a data issue.