Paynewest Insurance
Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings
Paynewest Insurance is the broker of record for 42 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 11,368 participants, most in MT, WA, OR. Commissions and fees average 13% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 1 and lost 3 broker-of-record relationships.
Employers
42
Participants
11,368
Premium placed
$3.6M
Commissions + fees
$482K
Comp rate
13%
Where the book is
Carriers on this book
- Mutual of Omaha 21
- Principal 9
- Dearborn Life Insurance 3
- New York Life Group Benefits (LINA) 2
- Transamerica Life Insurance 1
- Cincinnati Life Insurance 1
- EyeMed / Fidelity Security Life 1
- First Choice Health 1
- Delta Dental 1
- Voya 1
Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.
Group size and funding
- 0–49 participants 1
- 50–99 participants 6
- 100–249 participants 25
- 250–499 participants 8
- 500–999 participants 1
- 1,000–4,999 participants 1
- Self-funded 15 (36%)
- Fully insured 14 (33%)
- Self-funded (stop-loss) 10 (24%)
- No medical reported 3 (7%)
Recent wins (1)
| Employer | Previous broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Rimrock Foundation Billings, MT | Leavitt Group | 2025 |
Recent losses (3)
| Employer | New broker | Plan year |
|---|---|---|
| Onxmaps, Inc. Missoula, MT | Lockton | 2025 |
| Western Building Center Kalispell, MT | Marsh McLennan Agency | 2025 |
| Clearwater Federal Credit Union Missoula, MT | Marsh McLennan Agency | 2025 |
A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.
Largest employers
| Employer | Participants | Medical funding | Renews | Schedule A premium |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Consumer Direct Holdings, Inc. Missoula, MT | 3,725 | Self-funded | Jan | $3.1M |
| Easterseals-goodwill Northern Rocky Mountain, Inc. Great Falls, MT | 743 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $3.2M |
| Columbia Basin Health Association Othello, WA | 476 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Aug | $588K |
| Opportunity Bank of Montana Helena, MT | 329 | Self-funded | Jan | $191K |
| Clearwater Federal Credit Union Missoula, MT | 299 | Self-funded | Jan | $242K |
| Carroll College Helena, MT | 298 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.6M |
| Morrison-maierle, Inc. Helena, MT | 296 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $3.6M |
| Goodwill Industries of the Columbia Kennewick, WA | 264 | Self-funded | Jan | $55K |
| Cadwell Industries Inc Kennewick, WA | 261 | Self-funded | Jan | $134K |
| Ressler Motor Company Bozeman, MT | 257 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jul | $864K |
| New Columbia Fruit Packers, LLC Wenatchee, WA | 247 | Self-funded | Jan | $71K |
| Good Food Store Inc. Missoula, MT | 208 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $383K |
| Tamarack Management, Inc. Missoula, MT | 205 | Self-funded | Jan | $232K |
| Grange Cooperative Supply Association White City, OR | 198 | Self-funded | Jan | $156K |
| NAC, Inc. Spokane, WA | 191 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.0M |
| McCurley Integrity Dealerships, LLC Pasco, WA | 183 | Self-funded | May | $215K |
| Roach & Smith Distributors, Inc. Missoula, MT | 183 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Oct | $433K |
| Missoula Bone & Joint, LLC Missoula, MT | 171 | Self-funded | Jan | $276K |
| WFM Enterprises, LLC Garden City, ID | 163 | No medical reported | Jan | $31K |
| Opportunity Resources, Inc. Missoula, MT | 159 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.3M |
| WWC Physicians PC Walla Walla, WA | 159 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $664K |
| DJ&A, PC Missoula, MT | 157 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.3M |
| Rimrock Foundation Billings, MT | 156 | No medical reported | Apr | $91K |
| Lantis Enterprises, Inc. Spearfish, SD | 156 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.2M |
| Alternatives, Inc. Billings, MT | 153 | No medical reported | Jul | $233K |
| Pathway Enterprises, Inc. Medford, OR | 151 | Self-funded | Jan | $137K |
| GEM Innovation Schools Deary, ID | 141 | Fully insured | Sep | $1.9M |
| Rocky Mountain Supply, Inc. Belgrade, MT | 138 | Fully insured | Sep | $915K |
| Missoula Motor Company LLC Missoula, MT | 134 | Fully insured | Sep | $813K |
| J.M. Perry Institute of Trades Industries and Agriculture Yakima, WA | 129 | Self-funded | Oct | $98K |
| Easton Construction, Inc. Bozeman, MT | 121 | Fully insured | Jan | $2.0M |
| King Mountain Tobacco Co. Inc. White Swan, WA | 111 | Self-funded | Nov | $79K |
| Cochrane & Company Spokane, WA | 111 | Fully insured | Dec | $1.2M |
| NET Vendor LLC Tualatin, OR | 106 | Self-funded | Jan | $115K |
| FBS Consulting Services, LLC DBA Dakota Petroleum Services Killdeer, ND | 100 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.2M |
| Apyx Medical Corporation Clearwater, FL | 99 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.9M |
| The Waggoners Trucking Billings, MT | 94 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $312K |
| Hermann Brothers Logging & Construction, Inc. Port Angeles, WA | 91 | Self-funded | Jan | $9,833 |
| Dynojet Research, Inc. North LAS Vegas, NV | 78 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.2M |
| Conlin's Furniture, Inc. Billings, MT | 72 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Jan | $687K |
| Pipkin Inc. DBA Pipkin Construction Wenatchee, WA | 53 | Self-funded (stop-loss) | Aug | $213K |
| Western Mt Mental Health Center Missoula, MT | 2 | Fully insured | Jan | $1.8M |
From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.