Paynewest Insurance

Employee benefits broker · book of business from Form 5500 filings

Paynewest Insurance is the broker of record for 42 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 11,368 participants, most in MT, WA, OR. Commissions and fees average 13% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 1 and lost 3 broker-of-record relationships.

Employers
42
Participants
11,368
Premium placed
$3.6M
Commissions + fees
$482K
Comp rate
13%

See all brokers in Open5500 →

Where the book is

Carriers on this book

Number of employers where this broker is paid on that carrier's contracts.

Group size and funding

Recent wins (1)

EmployerPrevious brokerPlan year
Rimrock Foundation
Billings, MT
Leavitt Group2025

Recent losses (3)

EmployerNew brokerPlan year
Onxmaps, Inc.
Missoula, MT
Lockton2025
Western Building Center
Kalispell, MT
Marsh McLennan Agency2025
Clearwater Federal Credit Union
Missoula, MT
Marsh McLennan Agency2025

A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all. Acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

Largest employers

EmployerParticipantsMedical fundingRenewsSchedule A premium
Consumer Direct Holdings, Inc.
Missoula, MT
3,725Self-fundedJan$3.1M
Easterseals-goodwill Northern Rocky Mountain, Inc.
Great Falls, MT
743Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$3.2M
Columbia Basin Health Association
Othello, WA
476Self-funded (stop-loss)Aug$588K
Opportunity Bank of Montana
Helena, MT
329Self-fundedJan$191K
Clearwater Federal Credit Union
Missoula, MT
299Self-fundedJan$242K
Carroll College
Helena, MT
298Fully insuredJan$2.6M
Morrison-maierle, Inc.
Helena, MT
296Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$3.6M
Goodwill Industries of the Columbia
Kennewick, WA
264Self-fundedJan$55K
Cadwell Industries Inc
Kennewick, WA
261Self-fundedJan$134K
Ressler Motor Company
Bozeman, MT
257Self-funded (stop-loss)Jul$864K
New Columbia Fruit Packers, LLC
Wenatchee, WA
247Self-fundedJan$71K
Good Food Store Inc.
Missoula, MT
208Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$383K
Tamarack Management, Inc.
Missoula, MT
205Self-fundedJan$232K
Grange Cooperative Supply Association
White City, OR
198Self-fundedJan$156K
NAC, Inc.
Spokane, WA
191Fully insuredJan$2.0M
McCurley Integrity Dealerships, LLC
Pasco, WA
183Self-fundedMay$215K
Roach & Smith Distributors, Inc.
Missoula, MT
183Self-funded (stop-loss)Oct$433K
Missoula Bone & Joint, LLC
Missoula, MT
171Self-fundedJan$276K
WFM Enterprises, LLC
Garden City, ID
163No medical reportedJan$31K
Opportunity Resources, Inc.
Missoula, MT
159Fully insuredJan$1.3M
WWC Physicians PC
Walla Walla, WA
159Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$664K
DJ&A, PC
Missoula, MT
157Fully insuredJan$1.3M
Rimrock Foundation
Billings, MT
156No medical reportedApr$91K
Lantis Enterprises, Inc.
Spearfish, SD
156Fully insuredJan$1.2M
Alternatives, Inc.
Billings, MT
153No medical reportedJul$233K
Pathway Enterprises, Inc.
Medford, OR
151Self-fundedJan$137K
GEM Innovation Schools
Deary, ID
141Fully insuredSep$1.9M
Rocky Mountain Supply, Inc.
Belgrade, MT
138Fully insuredSep$915K
Missoula Motor Company LLC
Missoula, MT
134Fully insuredSep$813K
J.M. Perry Institute of Trades Industries and Agriculture
Yakima, WA
129Self-fundedOct$98K
Easton Construction, Inc.
Bozeman, MT
121Fully insuredJan$2.0M
King Mountain Tobacco Co. Inc.
White Swan, WA
111Self-fundedNov$79K
Cochrane & Company
Spokane, WA
111Fully insuredDec$1.2M
NET Vendor LLC
Tualatin, OR
106Self-fundedJan$115K
FBS Consulting Services, LLC DBA Dakota Petroleum Services
Killdeer, ND
100Fully insuredJan$1.2M
Apyx Medical Corporation
Clearwater, FL
99Fully insuredJan$1.9M
The Waggoners Trucking
Billings, MT
94Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$312K
Hermann Brothers Logging & Construction, Inc.
Port Angeles, WA
91Self-fundedJan$9,833
Dynojet Research, Inc.
North LAS Vegas, NV
78Fully insuredJan$1.2M
Conlin's Furniture, Inc.
Billings, MT
72Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$687K
Pipkin Inc. DBA Pipkin Construction
Wenatchee, WA
53Self-funded (stop-loss)Aug$213K
Western Mt Mental Health Center
Missoula, MT
2Fully insuredJan$1.8M

From public U.S. Department of Labor Form 5500 filings (Schedule A), as filed through the latest monthly refresh. Union and multiple-employer plans aren't included. Something wrong? Report a data issue.