Kistler Tiffany Benefits GEN Agency

Employee benefits broker. Book of business from Form 5500 filings, plan years to 2025.

Kistler Tiffany Benefits GEN Agency is the broker of record for 61 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 16,120 participants, most in PA, NJ, DE. Commissions and fees average 5.0% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 2 and lost 1 broker-of-record relationships.

Employers
61
Participants
16,120
Premium placed
$62,813,813
Commissions and fees
$3,125,562
Comp rate
5.0%
Broker changes
2 gained, 1 lost
Source
Form 5500, Schedule A

Largest employers

EmployerStateParticipantsFundingRenewsPremiumComp rateCarriers
IMAGINE360 Services LLCPA1,432Self-funded (stop-loss)Jan$2.7M7.7%Guardian, MetLife
Ace Hardware Home ServicesIL876Fully insuredOct$6.0M7.2%Guardian, UnitedHealthcare
Independence Realty Trust, Inc.PA852Fully insuredJan$464K3.3%Guardian
Zeus Fire and Security LLCPA588Fully insuredJan$7.3M3.4%Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans)
Agora Cyber Charter SchoolPA562UnknownJan$974K5.3%Principal
Brett Dinovi & Associates LLCNJ488Fully insuredJan$862K11%Cigna
VP Advantage Services, LLCPA488Fully insuredJan$2.2M7.8%Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), MetLife
M.davis & Sons, Inc.PA454Self-funded (stop-loss)Jul$869K5.0%The Standard
Lannett Company, Inc.PA420Fully insuredJan$548K5.7%MetLife, VSP
American College of PhysiciansPA389Fully insuredJan$6.4M0.0%Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans)
Valera Health, Inc.NY370Fully insuredApr$526K7.1%Lincoln Financial
Thompson Toyota, Inc.PA367Fully insuredMar$4.3M0.5%Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans), Keystone Health Plan East

Show all 61 employers

Carriers placed with

CarrierPremiumShare
Blue Cross Blue Shield (all plans)$30,303,70948%
UnitedHealthcare$7,209,28911%
Cigna$6,831,61711%
Keystone Health Plan East$4,069,6576.4%
Guardian$3,657,6605.8%
Aetna$2,341,8713.7%
MetLife$1,663,7092.6%
Principal$1,611,0662.5%

Premium on the Schedule A contracts this firm is paid on.

Employers by plan year

2 2019 3 2020 5 2021 5 2022 16 2023 46 2024 41 2025
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. 2025 is still filling in: many plans haven't filed yet.

Where the book is

StateEmployersParticipantsPremium
Pennsylvania3910,096$44,073,300
New Jersey92,306$4,453,144
Delaware2386$309,501
Illinois21,240$8,438,568
California1322$1,656,698
Connecticut1297$3,148,324
Florida1180$60,739
Georgia1123$105,362
Other states51,170$568,177
Total6116,120$62,813,813

Wins and losses, latest two plan years

Gained: 2 employers

EmployerPrevious brokerParticipants
Kulicke and Soffa IndustriesOneDigital322
Yale Cordage, Inc.HUB International143

Lost: 1 employers

EmployerNew brokerParticipants
Nephrology AssociatesPatriot Growth Insurance Services125

Net change: +1 employers. A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all; acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

What this page can't tell you: brokers appear only where they're listed on Schedule A, so plans that pay a consultant directly (Schedule C) aren't in this book. Plans under 100 participants often don't file. Something wrong? Report a data issue.