Hays Companies Insurance Agency

Employee benefits broker. Book of business from Form 5500 filings, plan years to 2025.

Hays Companies Insurance Agency is the broker of record for 47 employers with Form 5500 health and welfare filings, covering 29,726 participants, most in MN, WI, TX. Commissions and fees average 2.2% of the Schedule A premium it's paid on. In the latest two plan years it gained 1 and lost 5 broker-of-record relationships.

Employers
47
Participants
29,726
Premium placed
$21,269,171
Commissions and fees
$465,011
Comp rate
2.2%
Broker changes
1 gained, 5 lost
Source
Form 5500, Schedule A

Largest employers

EmployerStateParticipantsFundingRenewsPremiumComp rateCarriers
Refresco Beverages US Inc.FL4,667Self-fundedJan$9.3M2.5%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
Cmfg Life Insurance CompanyWI3,204Fully insuredJan$11.2M1.3%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
The Kinetic Group, Inc.MN3,078Self-fundedJan$3.0M3.7%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
Perdoceo Education CorporationIL2,034Self-fundedJan$2.2M4.0%Mutual of Omaha
Standard Motor Products, Inc.NY1,954Self-fundedJan$2.2M2.2%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
Spec's Family Partners, Ltd.TX1,694Fully insuredDec$7.9M0.6%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
Revelyst, Inc.CA1,449Self-fundedJan$820K7.0%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
Neighbors & Associates, Inc.KS710Self-funded (stop-loss)Jun$1.1M4.8%Mutual of Omaha
American Orthodontics CorporationWI693Self-fundedJan$247K12%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
Gopher Resource LLCMN673Self-fundedJan$909K1.9%Reliance Standard (Matrix)
Insulation Distributors, Inc.MN634Self-fundedJan$814K2.6%Mutual of Omaha
Continental Properties Company, IncWI630Self-fundedJan$462K2.6%Reliance Standard (Matrix)

Show all 47 employers

Carriers placed with

CarrierPremiumShare
Reliance Standard (Matrix)$16,342,90668%
Mutual of Omaha$5,969,53125%
UnitedHealthcare$1,805,7147.5%

Premium on the Schedule A contracts this firm is paid on.

Employers by plan year

16 2019 21 2020 26 2021 26 2022 30 2023 33 2024 38 2025
Source: Form 5500, Schedule A. 2025 is still filling in: many plans haven't filed yet.

Where the book is

StateEmployersParticipantsPremium
Minnesota85,034$2,134,746
Wisconsin85,705$6,116,678
Texas52,787$3,480,063
Florida35,003$5,632,449
Kansas31,250$509,352
Massachusetts3696$640,458
California21,638$116,035
Missouri2303$202,377
Other states137,310$2,437,013
Total4729,726$21,269,171

Wins and losses, latest two plan years

Gained: 1 employers

EmployerPrevious brokerParticipants
ESO Solutions, Inc.USI Insurance Services380

Lost: 5 employers

EmployerNew brokerParticipants
Macarthur CompanyBrown & Brown1,336
Wholesale Produce Supply, LLCBrown & Brown246
Surly Brewing Co.Brown & Brown148
Floe International, Inc.Brown & Brown130
Clayton Early Learning, Trustee, George W. Clayton TrustHUB International126

Net change: −4 employers. A change means last year's main broker isn't on the latest filing at all; acquisitions and rebrands can show up as changes.

What this page can't tell you: brokers appear only where they're listed on Schedule A, so plans that pay a consultant directly (Schedule C) aren't in this book. Plans under 100 participants often don't file. Something wrong? Report a data issue.